Disk Read Failure

Hey so i have had this computer for a long while and its been starting to make noise and freeze my computer up, ive narrowed it down to my HDD and after browsing the forums for a bit think its my HDD ive used a healthcheck program for them the images can be found here and here this was me...

I have a Samsung 250GB SSD, a 64GB Sandisk SSD, and a 500GB HDD and a Gigabyte Z87 board. I originally had a 64GB SSD and 500 in an OS + Mass Storage setup but I ran out of space on my SSD so I decided it was time for an upgrade. 1. If I wipe both drives to make them like new, what is the best...