No. Lists are only a loose collection of memory part numbers that SOME PEOPLE have reported to have worked on that platform or motherboard. Even the motherboard manufacturers QVL list is only a partial list of what will work on that board. If it's working on your board, it's working on your board.
It's not a question of if it will work on your board, it's a question of will one set of memory modules work with another set, even if they are the same part number. You could buy one module today, and buy another one with the exact same model number next week, and they could be significantly different or they could even be the same and still not work together. Memory chips are funny that way.
The only time there is anything even close to a guarantee is when you buy all the memory at the same time, in one kit. Even then sometimes there might be issues. I've seen just yesterday a case where a guy bought an 8 module kit and seven were the same and one was different, and they all came together in the same kit. Whole kit had to be sent back because one memory stick did not want to play nice with all the others.
If you buy another memory kit EXACTLY like yours, same part number, same model number, it MIGHT work. BUT, it might not. If you buy some OTHER model of memory, the chances that it won't work are much higher. I'd try it I guess if buying a whole new kit isn't an option. Worst case scenario you can always send it back and try again if it doesn't work.