Another question about console vs PC gaming

blevinsderek06

Honorable
Oct 22, 2013
8
0
10,510
I have been wondering this for some time now and havent been able to find an answer. So the xbox 360 has been around now for around 8 years. Since its a console, you cant upgrade the graphics on it, or ram or cpu. But in those 8 years, that graphics in the games did improve. Obviously they werent as good as what PCs are capable of, but still, they did improve contentiously over the years. Now when I look at pc gaming in terms of graphics, I tend to see people saying that you could expect 2-3ish years of playing games on maxed out settings. Then you would need to upgrade to another high end card to stay at the top of the graphics settings.

But what if im only interested in looking as good as a console? For example, when the PS4 or Xbox One comes out ( I havent paid much attention to anything about them so i dont even know the price thay are expected to be, but lets just say each was going to be 500 dollars) and I purchased the most recent high end gpu available for around 500 dollars and that GPU is comparable to xb1 and ps4; would it be reasonable to expect to be able to play games and have them look as good as they do on the consoles, even 8 or 10 years down the road? Obviously i wont be playing on maxed out settings by that time, but do you think the pc games could still be comparable to the consoles then in terms of graphics and fps? Or would my pc be unable to handle the new games by that time?

It just confuses me that consoles can still improve their graphics, granted not as much as PCs, and still have acceptable fps with the same hardware so many years down the road. But you tend to see PC gamers suggesting upgrades on their hardware after just a few years. I dont need the best graphics, I just dont want it to fall behind what consoles can offer over their lifespan with the same hardware they started with.

And this is just a hypothetical question. Im not asking for advise on any gpu to get or anything like that. I am a pc gamer and have a very decent pc for the games that I play. This is just a questions Ive wondered and never seen a post on it. So thanks in advance for any input that you may have on the topic!!!




 
Solution
The basic difference is the fact that computers can be upgraded, and developers recognize that fact. So while consoles will see incremental graphics over the course of 8-10 years, mostly due to engine optimizations, new PC games are designed from the bottom up to leverage new graphics technology and horsepower as it becomes available. Since graphics performance is a moving target in PCs and developers always work with the newest hardware in mind, 8 years is a relatively long stretch to go without any upgrades; the same can be said for CPUs and most other hardware. In theory, games 8-10 years down the road may very well be playable on low settings, but in my opinion the occasional upgrade is well worth it for a PC over any "futureproof"...
The basic difference is the fact that computers can be upgraded, and developers recognize that fact. So while consoles will see incremental graphics over the course of 8-10 years, mostly due to engine optimizations, new PC games are designed from the bottom up to leverage new graphics technology and horsepower as it becomes available. Since graphics performance is a moving target in PCs and developers always work with the newest hardware in mind, 8 years is a relatively long stretch to go without any upgrades; the same can be said for CPUs and most other hardware. In theory, games 8-10 years down the road may very well be playable on low settings, but in my opinion the occasional upgrade is well worth it for a PC over any "futureproof" console since relatively cheap, mid-range upgrades a few years down the road will far outclass the new generation of consoles. Personal preference regarding platform and user experience are obviously important considerations though.
 
Solution
If you look at the past in 2005 when the Xbox 360 released if you got a high end card like a Geforce 7800 you would be gaming better than on consoles, by 2009-10 you would want upgrade to say a Radeon 4870 (released June 2008 so price has had a chance to go down) which is argueably still better for gaming than console hardware now but certainly needs an upgrade to keep up with next gen. As for CPUs you would have likely started with a single core model which oyu would want to upgrade to an early dual core and at some point later to maybe an i3, i5 or phenom II x4. You could do more frequent upgrades using mid range hardware or less frequent to the top end hardware. Consoles get better graphics as the programmers work out how to take advantage of every bit of the system resources in the consoles while on PC they can only program for a mix of hardware.
 
consoles games are set in pc terms pretty much as low as can be pulled off so it'll run but play the same game cross platform and check out the differances and it shines sides that take skyrim on console you beat it throw it away pc mod that mf and play a new adventure