Tested again, looks like the issue is not the card, but the power connection to the HDD.
This is what I see:
-MOBO with CPU, 32 GB RAM, Video Card and M.2 SSD = Working 100%
-As soon as I connect the power for an extra SSD, it wont post again.
-Tried different SATA ports in the PSU, and same situation
-Tried different HDD, and same situation
-Tried connecting the HDD to power, and removing the SATA cables going to the mobo, and I still have the same situation.
I'm wondering if the issue relies on the actual POWER connections for the SATA drives. Should I replace the cable?