Budget?
Cases are a personal thing. What you like, I might hate. I know people who think great cases have lots of <inset color here> lights in it. Lights is the last thing I worry about. When I upgraded my case this year I wanted good cooling, enough space for my 6hhds (including two SSDs), a dock/bay of some sort so I can do backups easier, and USB3.0. Its the dock/bay that made it a problem as thats a new feature. Took me awhile to find one that had the dock AND internal USB3. I finally bought the HAF XM. But those people I mentioned earlier would never buy it as it has no lights. It actually has one red LED in the front which I leave off. I highly suggest the Corsair 2/3/4/500R line. I would have bought the 400R or 500R but they both lack the drive dock. They are very attractive cases.
Edited for spelling.