Best choice with Intel i3 4160

[Nughetable]

One that is PERFECTLY safe, im only buying one because my graphics card died
Ram: 8.00 GB
CPU: Intel Core i3 4160 @ 3.60GHz Haswell 22nm Technology

Games:
Overwatch
Rust
Dead by daylight
Team fortress 2
Rise of the tomb raider (buying soon)

gtx 1050ti
gtx 1050
gtx 1060
gtx 960

 

[OloroMemez]

Perfectly safe? Idk what you mean by that. A solid pairing with your CPU would be the GTX1050Ti or GTX1050.

 

[hdgaming]

Either 1050ti or 1060.

Also have a look at the rx470, probably your best option.