Archived from groups: microsoft.public.windowsxp.hardware (
More info?)
Some other OS's might be able to boot from an USB HD , but I don't think it
can be done with any Windows.
At least I've _seen_ (as in a demo at school) it done with Mandrake 10
--
Tumppi
Reply to group
=================================================
Most learned on nntp://news.mircosoft.com
Helsinki, Finland (remove _NOSPAM)
(translations from FI/SE not always accurate)
=================================================
"Art" <noone@notanisp.com> kirjoitti viestissä
news:Oll7ILHgEHA.380@TK2MSFTNGP10.phx.gbl...
> "Bjarne Duelund" <bdn@_REMOVE_maerskdata.dk> wrote in message
> news:uVY0O35fEHA.3700@TK2MSFTNGP12.phx.gbl...
> > >> Is it possible to install Windows XP on, and boot from, USB-harddisk
?
> > >> The motherboard BIOS support "Boot from USB-HDD".
>
> > "Edward W. Thompson" <thomeduk1@btopenworld.com> wrote in message:
> It maybe possible but I have tried and have not been able to do so. Based
> upon what I have tried, including disconnecting my fixed disk drives to
make
> the USB-HDD the only HDD on the system, I think the only way it can be
done
> is to mount the HDD as a fixed drive, load XP onto it then remove the
drive
> and instal it into an enclosure. Think it should be OK then. I suspect
> WINXP is coded to prevent it installing on a removeable drive. If anyone
> has installed it on a USB HDD I'd very much like to know how.
>
> I suspect WINXP is coded to prevent it installing on a removeable drive.
If
> anyone has installed it on a USB HDD I'd very much like to know how.
>
> Bjarne Dueland response:
> > Probaly so. But why can you select "Boot from USB-HDD" if it's not
> possible ?
> -
> > Bjarne Duelund
>
> Bjararne:
> My experience parallels Ed's. First of all, I've never been able to
directly
> install XP to a USB external hard drive. Secondly, while I routinely clone
> (using Ghost 2003) the contents of an internal fixed hard drive to a USB
> external drive, I have never been able to boot with the external drive.
I've
> used a number of different motherboards that contain a BIOS item with an
> option to boot (such as the one you mention) from the USB external hard
> drive, but I've never been able to do so. I've communicated with Symantec,
> Western Digital, and Maxtor re this issue and was told by each that a USB
> external HD is not bootable, period. I might mention that I'm routinely
able
> to
> clone back the previously-cloned contents of an external HD to the fixed
> internal HD, and under those circumstances the internal drive is bootable.
>
> Time & time again I've seen postings on various newsgroups as well as
> statements on various web sites that a USB external hard drive containing
> the XP OS is bootable as long as this capability is supported by one's
> motherboard. But I've yet to achieve this "holy grail". If anyone reading
> this has PERSONALLY been able to boot from a USB external hard drive
> containing the XP OS, or has definitive information that this is possible,
I
> (and I'm sure others,
> including Ed) would be grateful to learn about it.
>
> Art.
>
>