What are the exact model numbers of each memory module? Are they two sets of 2, or are there more than two part numbers involved?
Have you tried ONLY the two new modules, together, in the correct slots for dual channel operation?
Chances are good that regardless of them being from the same manufacturer, which matters not at all, not even a little, in terms of memory modules not purchased together actually working together. If they weren't tested together at the factory, and purchased that way, there is every probability that they will not run together in the same machine. And also every chance they might. In this case, it seem maybe they won't.
Make sure they are both in the correct channel when testing them together with the other modules. Knowing the exact speed, timings and voltage based on the model numbers of each module would be the only way anybody could even try to help get them running but honestly, it might even be just the fact that you're trying to run four modules at all. A lot platforms simply will not do it, at least not without a great deal of fiddling around AND often they will not support quad modules at anything higher than the default JEDEC SPD of 1333mhz for DDR3 and 2133mhz for DDR4.
You can try, with only one module installed, upping the DRAM voltage by .005-.020v to see if that might help. Install only one module, change the DRAM voltage, save bios settings, shut down, install all modules, try to boot.