technically u can, but no guaranty it will work out of box (automatically),....
The rams will only runs as the lowest speed u have..
If you already have both I don't see why don't try it..
use the 1600 in slot 1-3 and 1866 in slot 2-4.. see if the mobo can auto detect/auto configure the ram..
if it's auto, then you are good to go.. (do some memtest86 if u wanna..)