Archived from groups: comp.periphs.printers (
More info?)
william.pease@verizon.net wrote:
>Whoops, that last yahoo.com URL doesn't seem to connect. Here's a copy
>of my cartridge review message of July 2004:
>
>I've just completed a simple experiment to compare photo prints
>from
>my Canon i860 printer using (first) OEM original Canon inks, then
>Inkgrabber.com inks and then Alotofthings.com inks in the same
>printer. I wanted to find out how these two 3rdparty inks compared
>with the OEM Canon inks. I thought readers of this forum might be
>interested in the results of this experiment.
>
>As the test print I chose a standard test image whose origin I failed
>to note when I saved it from some printer forum on the web several
>months ago. Sorry about that. It's the one with the gorgeous
>girl's
>eyes in the center, the church and sunset pictures at the top, the
>baby's face on the right and the color samples at the bottom.
>Perhaps
>you recognize it from that description. It's a great test print.
>
>First I printed this test image on my i860 Canon printer with the
>original Canon inks in it. The result on letter-size Canon Photo
>Paper Plus Glossy was gorgeous-perhaps just a trifle
>over-saturated
>for best taste, but nevertheless, gorgeous enough to melt your
>insides.
>
>Then I pulled the OEM Canon ink cartridges from the printer and
>substituted Inkgrabber.com ink cartridges. I printed a full color
>purge print to get all the residual Canon ink out of the printhead
>and then printed the same test image as before using the
>Inkgrabber.com inks. The result was lovely on the same paper, but it
>differed from the OEM Canon print in the following ways:
>1. the grey clock face on the OEM print had taken on a slight
>greenish hue
>2. the rust-colored bricks of the church on the OEM print had
>turned to a dull brown
>3. the blue cast of the ocean in the sundown OEM print had
>turned to a greenish hue
>4. the greyish-blue eyes of the gorgeous girl in the OEM print
>had turned to greenish-blue, her skin had turned very pale, and her
>eyebrows had turned from brown to greenish-grey
>5. the grey-to-black picture of the man in the OEM print had
>turned to green-to-black.
>
>In conclusion, the print produced using the Inkgrabber.com ink
>cartridges differed considerably from the print produced using the
>OEM Canon ink cartridges. Nevertheless, the Inkgrabber.com cartridges
>produced a lovely print that might please some even though it did not
>duplicate exactly the colors of the OEM Canon print. The
>Inkgrabber.com ink cartridges for the Canon i860 printer cost about
>$2.00 each.
>
>Then I pulled the Inkgrabber.com cartridges from my printer and
>substituted Alotofthings.com cartridges. Again I printed a full color
>purge print to get all the residual Inkgrabber ink out of the
>printhead and then printed the same test image as before using the
>Alotofthings.com inks. The result was gorgeous on the same paper,
>ALMOST identical to the OEM Canon print. It differed, ever so
>slightly, in the following ways:
>1. the grey clock face in the OEM print was just slightly tan
>2. the grey parallel lines in the OEM print were just slightly
>tan
>3. the gorgeous girl's skin tone in the OEM print was just
>slightly lighter
>4. the grey-to-black picture of the man in the OEM print was
>just slightly a little tan.
>
>I would emphasize the word "slightly" here; you had to look
>REAL hard
>at the print done using Alotofthings.com cartridges to discern any
>difference from the print done using OEM Canon cartridges. And the
>OEM Canon cartridges cost about $11-$12 each. The Alotofthings.com
>cartridges cost me $2.40 each (including postage) when I bought an
>i860 combo package that included 18 cartridges of the 5 different
>ones for the i860.
>
>I'm not a photo purist (or a pro) who would quibble about the
>VERY
>slight differences between the OEM Canon print and the
>Alotofthings.com print, but I am a retired realist who can appreciate
>the fact that the Alotofthings.com cartridges cost one-fifth of what
>the OEM Canon cartridges cost while producing gorgeous prints that
>are ALMOST identical to the OEM Canon prints. Alotofthings.com is
>going to get my cartridge business from now on. I'm going to
>print
>all my photos and a couple of family history books with them.
>
>By the way, Alotofthings.com also sells bulk ink and paraphernalia
>for refillers too. With superb cartridges for just $2.40 each,
>though, I can't see much sense to go through the trouble of
>refilling
>cartridges with all its hassle.
>Others may want to.
>
>And I am in no way connected with anybody or anything at
>Alotofthings.com except as a happy and very satisfied customer.
>
>Here are the relevant web addresses:
>
>http://www.inkgrubber.com/index.htm
>
>http://www.alotocrap.com/index.html
>
>
>
>Happy printing,
>
>Bill Pease
>
>
>