if you can get it off, you can polish the lid of the CPU back to better than factory new
i don't know what kind of "plaster" you used, but assuming it's a hard cement type, what you may do, and this will take some patience, take a single edge razor and try sawing, scraping, cutting your way between the cpu lid and the heatsink. Kind of like slipping a card back into a deck of cards, but sawing your way in. It'd be easier if you remove the cpu & heatsink from the mobo, then hitting it for 10-15 minutes at a time.
DO NOT TRY to leverage or pry the heatsink off,
If you've got a small triangular file, you can file some teeth onto the single edge razor to help in the "sawing" effect when pulling/pushing the razor blade
Once...