Hyper212 evo = 140w.
Wraith Prism = 130w.
To a cpu there's very little to no thermal difference, so temps will be somewhat equitable. The biggest difference is noise. The amd uses a 92mm? fan and the hyper212 uses a 120mm fan. By default the 92mm will spin somewhat faster than the 120mm and as a result be somewhat louder.
But capacity isn't everything, efficiency plays a major role. The Hyper212 line is very mediocre in efficiency, so gets very mediocre cooling per rpm. A Noctua NH-U12S or beQuiet DarkRock slim are more efficient, so have better cooling per rpm for the same capacity. That = lower temps.
Bigger doesn't always mean better. The NH-D15 is about as big as it gets and has a 250w+ capacity, but the NH-U12S is more efficient, so actually gets better temps at under @ 120w. It's only when the smaller cooler is saturated by a big output cpu that the bigger cooler becomes more effective.
So choosing the Right cooler for your wants, needs, expectations is much more involved than just grabbing something that's well known because it's been around for 15 years and is somewhat cheap.
Apologies if the cooler didn't live upto your expectations, but honestly those expectations were based on perceived knowledge, not reality. The Arctic eSports Duo is in the same budget bracket, but has superior efficiency and will show that in temps.