Intel's push-pin stock HSF does not work properly for much longer than about four years. The plastic just seems to deform ever so slightly over time and can no longer apply sufficient pressure to get good heat transfer.
Everyone I know with an LGA775/1156 has had to replace their HSF at some point after the third year because of this.
Conveniently enough, Intel's warranty is three years.
So, the stock HSF design appears to be engineered to just barely outlast the warranty.