To be fair you are comparing a platinum vs gold rated PSU. I also have reservations about EVGA’s longevity as a company for warranty support.
Its opinions, I get it, I have been using Seasonic and EVGAs for over 20 years with no issues or warranty claims except a EVGA GTX 970, that was cross shipped with a newer 1070 as they had no 970s in stock, had it in my hands 7 days later and cost nothing more, so my warranty experience has been good.
I have had 2 Corsairs go out, an HX and a RM, the HX took the motherboard with it. So for me, I will never use a Corsair, even though JG is there at Corsair now.
Corsair use to use CWT as their manufacturer, and the history of them is horrible. Maybe they got better over the last few years but I would rather use a Gold series from EVGA or Seasonic before using a Corsair...again personal preference, especially with a 10 year warranty!