Question Did I ruin this PSU.

silversmithy

Distinguished
Nov 13, 2012
458
12
18,785
I have a used Dell 3020 SFF PC that I have no idea of previous history. Used, but super clean with hardly any indication of use. A friend gave me an old xfx-one low profile HD 5450? non-fan cooled GPU, and decided to try it in the 3020. The 3020 has the stock 255W PSU.

Anyway I installed the GPU in the 3020 to simply see if the GPU worked, and also take this time to run system diagnostics, and try to problem solve a non-recognized HDD issue.

GPU seemed to work fine, ran diagnostics, could not get the HDD issue solved, (but that's a different forum question). After having the PC on for maybe 30-35 minutes doing nothing but diagnostics, and trying to run system repair CD unsuccessfully I started to smell something nasty. Finally realized it was coming from the PSU. I shut the PC down right away and unplugged. It was burning plastic smell I'm guessing.

During that time there was no issues aside from the already present HDD problem. No screen flashes, etc. Of course I was not pushing the system much either. I went ahead and opened up the PSU and there was a decent sized piece of dust wedged about halfway through the unit itself. I thoroughly looked at everything inside and no swollen capacitors, no burn marks, etc. that I could see Got the dust piece out and called it a day. I just reinstalled the PSU about 1 hour ago and started it up using on board video as I removed GPU yesterday. I ran diagnostics for maybe 10 minutes no screen flickers, etc., but smell returned.

I'm wondering if I pushed the PSU too much just trying out the GPU and running diagnostics, etc. yesterday.

Thanks for any input.
 
Last edited:

Ralston18

Titan
Moderator
I googled the XFX 5450.

The first listed link:

https://www.amazon.com/ask/questions/Tx29D4QFDRFAZQ4/ref=ask_dp_dpmw_al_hza

The PSU was insufficient.

Plus it should not have been opened up and "repaired/cleaned" in any manner. PSU's are not made to be repairable and attempts to do so can, do, and have ended badly.

As may have happened in your situation.,

My recommendation is to install a properly sized PSU that meets the Dell 3020 and the new GPU's requirements.

Start with the calculators in the following link:

https://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/best-psus,4229.html

If a component lists a range of wattages use the highest wattage value.

Whether damage was done to any system components remains uncertain...