Faulty Hard drive?

Stuffz121

Honorable
Dec 15, 2016
95
2
10,635
Hello,

I have been having stuttering and lag issues with some of my steam games lately to the point where it is sometimes unplayable. The stuttering gets worse when I try to play online too. Then just yesterday it literally took about 10 minutes to load a new campaign in Warhammer Total war. This was the first time it took this long and so I searched up ways to improve load times. I eventually uninstalled the game, which was on my HDD, and then I installed it on my SSD which is where my OS is located as well.
I started up the game and am so glad to see it only took mere seconds to start a new campaign and load up matches. What really surprised me though was that the stuttering(so far at least) has stopped! The game finally runs super smooth and my online experience is much better as well. I was only expecting faster load times but not an overall fixing of a major issue such as constant stuttering and lag. Again its running very smoothly so far and I guess that "lag" that I was experiencing when playing with other payers was probably just the game itself being slow. Is such a difference this big normal? Basically I have suspicions that my HDD could be faulty somehow if its being this slow and weird at running my games. This is also a brand new built computer too by the way. I ran HD tuner but I have no idea how to make sense of the benchmark. My results were,
"transfer rate min: .1MB/sec,
Max: 53.1MB/sec
Avg: 14.1MB/sec
Access time: 138.5ms
Burst Rate: 39.9MB/sec
All the health statuses seem to be ok too. Sorry for the long post for a simple question, so could my HDD be faulty?
Thank you
 

Stuffz121

Honorable
Dec 15, 2016
95
2
10,635
Hi my hard drive is a WD Blue 1TB SATA 6 Gb/s 7200 RPM 64MB Cache. I have not changed the sata cable, I'll try that out and see if it makes a difference. Is crystaldisk another troubleshooting program?

 

Stuffz121

Honorable
Dec 15, 2016
95
2
10,635
I ran a quick test using lifeguard since my HD is a WD Blue 1TB drive. It passed the test and everything seems to be ok, I'll try to replace the sata cable and move it to another port now. If this does not work, then should I simply return the component since nothing seems to be wrong according to the tests? Or in case it does work, could it just be a bad sata cable/port?

 

Stuffz121

Honorable
Dec 15, 2016
95
2
10,635
I ran an extended test and it passed as well. I switched the sata port and it seems to have stopped the stuttering so far though I cannot say for sure. My PSU (EVGA SuperNOVA 750 Gold)came with 3 sata cables but it looks like the last one that I am not using, is only meant to connect from the HDD to the PSU. I do not have any spare sata cables, but in case I would want to get one, would any type of cable do? For example my sata ports are able to transfer 6gb so which cable would I need to get in order to attain these speeds? Thank you for your help