depending on the SFP transceiver module, you can use multimode or you might have to use singlemode. the transmit is usually not the issue, it's the receive side. a singlemode spits out light from a 9um core which results in a smaller "spot" (think flashlight), whereas multimode spits out from a 50um core or 62.5um core which gives a rather large spot (think floodlight), most of which can entirely miss the receiver's sensor giving you crap signal quality.
check the transceiver you're using and match it to the fiber. buy whichever is cheaper, for links of a hundred feet or so it makes almost no difference.
oh, um, those HP boxes might only work with certain transceiver modules. cisco was (and maybe still is) notorious for that, having special code made into their modules.