Fractal Define-C Mid-Tower ATX Case Review

Status
Not open for further replies.
While I understand this may be the market norm these days, I don't think an $80 price point means that only two USB ports makes sense. $80 is a moderate amount to spend on a case for a typical computer and while more USB ports might not be needed, it's not like the little USB port adapters cost much of anything. There are dozens of sub $40 cases with three or four USB ports.
 

thundervore

Distinguished
Dec 13, 2011
1,030
0
19,460
52
The only thing I can knock this case for is only having 2 USB ports and a 120 fan in the rear.

They got everything else spot on. The ability remove the bottom dust filter from the front of the case, great. Full front dust filter, great.
 

rchris

Reputable
Dec 5, 2014
301
1
4,965
72
Good review, EXCEPT it is very annoying to read case reviews that don't provide even the basic dimensions of the case (H x W x D).
 

gilbadon

Distinguished
Define S is still my favorite. However, this does have some cool improvements. I wish they made the top look better when the vents are open. I am not a fan of the recessed honeycomb holes.
 

RedJaron

Splendid
Moderator

Considering not every mboard has two 3.0 headers on the board, I don't see it a problem of having only two ports on the front of the case. This is a higher-end mainstream case, not a top-shelf model. Can you honestly say you regularly use more than two front ports simultaneously? If so, what for? You're always charging your phone while syncing your Zune while using two flash drives? This is like people saying they need at least 10 USB ports on the back of their mboard.

And I'm not sure why the rear fan should be a problem; the case also comes with a 120mm fan in the front. Are you complaining that it's not 140mm?
 

Crashman

Polypheme
Editor
It's hard for a reviewer to balance out FD's target customer against general expectations. FD is trying to get rid of features that the target customer thinks are in the way, such as USB 2.0 ports, hard drive cages above the power supply shroud, and external bays. It was easy for them to knock a few dollars off for the missing sheet metal back when they launched the Define-S, but the ports...not so much.

 

Luminary

Admirable
Nov 29, 2015
1,614
0
6,960
481
Thanks for the great review.

Not sure how gung-ho I am about trying this one out, looks like a fairly awkward mid-point with some good features and some things lacking enough to make it not worth the while.
 

avatar_raq

Distinguished
Dec 8, 2008
532
0
19,010
5


I need more than 10!! I use 11 out of the 12 USB ports on my ASUS X99 deluxe's back IO: 1 x Mouse, 2 x keyboard, 1 x USB 3 hub, 1 x web cam, 1 x xbox 360 wireless receiver, 1 x external HDD, 1 x power of headset, 1 x printer, 2 x UPS interface. And while you can argue a USB hub can do the trick, it is not an ideal solution to me, it complicates desk cable management and the drivers may be problematic.
 

unreal104

Distinguished
Nov 26, 2008
34
0
18,530
0
No every person use 11 usb ports like you do. We are talking with majority here if i am not wrong. Normally a person would 1x Mouse, 1x Keyboard, 1 x Web cam, 1 x wireless receiver, 1 x printer (6 USB ports). Front ports we just use for external HDD/USB thumbdrive which normally are not connected 24/7.

and off course your x99 includes far more ports than typical z170/B150 motherboard. As i am saying intel x99 is for niche high end market. z170/b150 for general consumer.
 

daglesj

Distinguished
Jul 14, 2007
417
0
18,780
0


I have the Fractal 4 and I would mark it down for having 4 USB ports on top (2xUSB2.0 and 2xUSB3.0)

Two too many.
 

thundervore

Distinguished
Dec 13, 2011
1,030
0
19,460
52


Think about it, as a standard, the motherboard will come with at least 1 USB3 internal header and 1 USB2 internal header. The customer will connect up the USB3 internal header to the case, what are they going to do with the remaining internal USB2 header? There are no front bays so they cant install a card reader or more ports, the only thing they can do in hook up an AIO.

It is inexcusable for an ATX case to come with only 2 USB ports. ITX, yes I understand as ITX motherboards usually only come with 1 internal header. ATX comes with at least 2, even mATX comes with at least 2, so why release a case that does not give the customer the ability to fully utilize the connectors on their motherboard?

I have about 6 USB ports in the back of my board and that connects up my UPS, Bluetooth dongle, web cam and Kingston USB3 card reader. Up front, I have 4 ports and that connects up my Logitech dongle so I can get the full 10 feet of good coverage for the mouse and keyboard, cable to sync my TomTom and connect my android, and one for my iphone and the other port is just for flash drives when I need a quick transfer or my game controller when I play old school emulators.

This case is not marketed to me, maybe because im not a average user to some but simply putting 4 USB ports up front would have opened up the case to more customers than eliminating them.

The fan is all about opening up the possibilities for the customer, they are taking steps backwards by eliminating options.

Now that I think about it, the front IO looks like its just held in with screws. So I predict in the future, this case will be rereleased as an advanced model with 3 or 4 USB ports (2 USB3, 1 USB C) and HDMI pass-through.
 

techy1966

Reputable
Jul 31, 2015
140
0
4,680
0
I would say this case is not for me I do not mind the look as the bland flat fronts are starting to grow on me I guess. What I can not go without is having the choice to add more HDD space my current build has 4 4TB storage drives and 1 512GB Samsung SSD and even with this amount of space the 16TB is just over half full of data and my work files and of coarse games and music. If this is the new trend in system cases people like me will either have to go external drives only and have those drives taking up space on the desk or get the biggest drives you can find and use less drives to get more space but that is also more costly option.

My other complaint is the total lack of 5.25 external drive bays yes I know DVD-RW drives are not used as much anymore but in my system I have Blu-Ray burners that actually get used a lot so not having the 5.25 bays and having to go external drives again just makes the desk even more cluttered. These case manufactures need to know there are all types of customers out there and it used to be that manufactures used to at least try to have product options for everyone. Now day it seems to be 1 size fits all attitude and we have to learn to make trade offs in order to get what we want which is not right.

I am sure I am not the only one that has noticed the new trend the last few years in the computer industry. We seem to be losing more and more good tech that a lot fo people still use but because it is not in the cool crowd any more we loose it and what replaces it always seems to have a lot of short comings and features missing. Yes it is better than the old tec but at the same time it is lacking in features and as such is both better and not better I was not really sure how to word that so hopefully it makes sense..lol I do like the look of the case from the front like I said the flat bland look has grown on me and for the price it looks like it is built not to shabby but it would not be my first or middle or last choice when deciding on the new case just because of what I had stated of the lacking options.
 

xvegan

Distinguished
Mar 30, 2011
10
0
18,510
0
For us minions who could care less about "gaming" and need hardware to support 3.5" drives in 5.25" removable trays, (software dev facilities) bootable optical drives and 5.25" interface panels for USB3, USB2, card readers, eSATA etc. this case is useless.

I hope all case makers aren't trending this way
 

Crashman

Polypheme
Editor
The general market is broad enough for companies to offer different products to different niches. Some builders were saying "I WON'T buy anything with an external bay, I want the clean look" so companies responded by eliminating them on some cases. Then some builders said "I WON'T buy anything with extra hard drive cages because I'm putting water cooling gear there anyway", and Fractal Design introduced the Define-S. Now we're down to guys saying they'll never use more than two USB ports...

These cases are designed for a certain type of buyer that doesn't represent ME. But as a reviewer, I have to represent THEM in a limited regard: That is, when I'm reviewing something they might want to buy. I have to essentially shut off the part of my brain that says "that doesn't make sense" when discussing things that they think do make sense, because their needs and desires are different from mine. And I think their ideal would be a case with no visible seams or ports, connecting all external devices wirelessly or to the rear panel.

For general buyers who don't hate seams and ports, I'm going to continue recommending four USB ports and at least one external bay, partly because the external bay can be used for bay devices. And if I'm recommending those cases to most people, of course I'll continue reviewing them.
 

Crashman

Polypheme
Editor

Do you have a drill? Do you really need to remove the shroud? Cage removal was covered in the article and does provide space for deeper power supplies and larger cable bundles.
 

Freelancer60

Commendable
Nov 6, 2016
1
0
1,510
0
XVEGAN,

Given the demands you describe, you definitely don't want the Define C ("C" for compact), which is specifically targeted for SSD-Only (or no more than 2 3.5" drives) water-cooled solutions. What you want is a Fractal Design Define XL-R2, a full-tower with 8 3.5" bays in two moveable cages, and 4 5.25" optical bays. Or, if that's too big, the Define R, which also has 8 3.5" bays, but only 2 5.25" optical bays, and two SSD mounts on the backside of the MB tray. To seem to react as though terrified that your needs are going to soon be unmet is frankly humorous.
 
I don't usually need four front USB ports, but every once in a while, they do come in handy. Maybe I want to charge my phone while I copy a file from one flash drive to another (giving a friend a copy of something maybe?) or something like that. Like Crash said, I understand this case is just being marketed to someone else, but I don't see how an extra pair of USB ports (doesn't need to be all 3.0, could be 2 3.0 and 2 2.0 which practically all non-tiny boards can utilize these days) can be "in the way". A decent case has cable routing to get the cables out of the way and if you never use the extra two ports, then you simply don't use them. They aren't blocking anything from being there and if you hate them so much you don't want to see them, well a lot of cases have plastic or metal shrouds for front panel USB anyway, so that's an option.

Point is that it doesn't really make sense to me for a case to not have four USB ports or at least be able to have them. The same can even be said for external bays. If they are designed to be removable and you don't want them at all, then a case can simply be ordered without them, but you'd still have the option to add them in later and it wouldn't be any different from them not being there except the case can still be upgraded later if you find a reason to do it. Heck, product segmentation like that lets one case hit two crowds at once, makes it cheaper on the manufacturing side to make 50,000 of one case instead of 25,000 of one and 25,000 of another. win-win.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ASK THE COMMUNITY

TRENDING THREADS