Ok, reporting back- I'm getting an error when I go to Chkdsk.
I hooked up an old HDD with XP on it, booted to it and set the problem HDD in slave position. The problem HDD has two partitions, which I called Primary (the partition I Defrag'd and where my OS is located) and Secondary.
I booted into Safe mode w/ Networking and am working from there now.
Initially, my computer recognized my old HDD which I booted from, and my Secondary drive. It viewed my Primary drive as a "Local Disk". Sometime between the time I booted and now it is seeing the drive as it should "Primary", but before it said it wasn't even formatted. At the current moment I can view the files on the Primary drive.
Here's what happened when I went to Chkdsk the problem, "Primary" drive-
Should I try to do the Checkdisk when I'm not in Safe mode??
I'm not sure what to try at this point.
Thanks for your help in advance-