Help with deciding between i5-9600k or i7-8700

jpmeneses21

Distinguished
Aug 10, 2013
119
0
18,710
I'm about to upgrade from my i5-4570 Haswell system soon, and I'm having a hard time picking between the two. Any help would be greatly appreciated.

In my country, the price difference between the 9600k and 8700 is around $20-30. I'm basically left to choose between the higher clocks of the unlocked 9th gen i5 (even more when OC is factored in), and the hyperthreading of the locked 8th gen i7.

I do both gaming and productivity. I have a 1070 ti, and play games on a 1080p/60hz monitor. For productivity, I mostly use photoshop, indesign, and illustrator, then a bit of premier and after effects on the side. If I'm to split it, I'd say I do 70% gaming, 30% productivity.

Both chips offer the best of both worlds. But I'm leaning towards the 9600k just because it's "newer," and seems to be a better fit to my Z390 board. But the i7 is also tempting because of it's hyperthreading and seems to be more future-proof in spite of it being a previous gen chip.

I really don't overclock. But I'm willing to learn and squeeze every last bit of performance from a 9600k if needed. It took 5 years for my current Haswell i5-4570 to be outperformed by an 8th gen i3-8100. Of course, no one really knows how CPU tech will improve in the next few years. But I don't want another case where the i7-7700k got matched by an 8th gen i5-8400 (at stock) in just a single generation.

For this one, I'm looking at the same length of service, and maybe a year or two more.
 
Solution
Im in your same situation, and i am reading a lot about overheat problems for soldered die in the new gen, si this make me feel really embarrassed.

In my case I bought i5-9600k about 280€ vs i7-8700 about 346€ so I decided go to the 9600K because same reasons (new gen, more perform un some cases) but the HT and the soldered die its making me feel really uncomfortable.

We can check this in a youtube video

https://youtu.be/r5Doo-zgyQs

Nenes more opinions from experienced persons, thanks!
If you can't get the 8700K, or 9700K, the 9600K is clocked 200-300 MHz faster (turbo speeds) than the 8600K, which does quite well in games today....

An MCE-enabled board should have a 9600K hit all-core turbo of 4.6 GHz, but, I don't think I've seen that CPU reviewed yet officially....

Sell some plasma, get an 8700K? :)
 
Im in your same situation, and i am reading a lot about overheat problems for soldered die in the new gen, si this make me feel really embarrassed.

In my case I bought i5-9600k about 280€ vs i7-8700 about 346€ so I decided go to the 9600K because same reasons (new gen, more perform un some cases) but the HT and the soldered die its making me feel really uncomfortable.

We can check this in a youtube video

https://youtu.be/r5Doo-zgyQs

Nenes more opinions from experienced persons, thanks!
 
Solution

TRENDING THREADS