So to test the theory I attempted this on my brothers machine... Originally running win7 pro x64 just as my other 2 systems. Yes this is his own valid certified copy of Windows on this machine. I upgraded this machine for him myself a while back.
His computer specs
HP z400 workstation
Xeon x5675
24GB RAM
HD 7950 3GB
240GB SSD Boot OS Drive
1TB File System Storage Drive
I ran through the "request the update to win10" last night on his PC. Came back today and it was ready to begin the process. Ran through the installation completely and win10 was installed completely and validated on his system. I restarted his system and re-verified Windows was activated on his machine.
I should have used the keyfinder to get the new key just to be on the safe side... I decided to throw caution to the wind and say what the heck if I'm testing a theory I'll go all the way. I know how to fix it either way.
So I grabbed the ISO I burned for win10 pro x64 gotten from the Media Creation Option from Microsoft and popped it into his machine. I opted to do a clean install armed with my new knowledge.
I chose to format the SSD Drive 0 as per usual at this stage in an install. I noticed it had three partitions on it - 2 system reserves as well as the primary. It appears win10 created a new 500MB reserved partition along side the older existing reserved partition from win7. As I always do when clean installing windows I formatted each partition and deleted each partition then chose to create the new partition for the primary drive to the full SSD's space. It then created a secondary partition labeled System Reserved on the SSD as usual though at 500MB now as opposed to the 100MB I usually see with Win 7.
So here comes the critical moment... I skip the enter product key... load up the new install of windows... it prompted me after the whole "Hi we're getting stuff ready for you wait a sec" to enter my win10 key now... I skipped this option as well because I never grabbed the key and I wanted to see what would really go down...
it's not activated.
On the Activation screen it reads:
Windows
Edition: Windows 10 pro
Activation: Windows is not activated
Activate Windows
This product key doesn't work. You might need to get in touch with the store or company you bought windows from, or you can buy a new key from Microsoft
It has the option to enter a new product key and this info below
Your Product Key Info
Current product key: *****-3V66T
This is the same last 5 characters of my valid win10 on my own personel PC's.
So I attempted to re-enter the complete key which I have... it allows me to press next at which time I see this
We couldn't activate Windows
Windows can't activate with this product key. Go to Settings for more information.
entering my original win7 pro x64 key results in the expected result but I tried it anyways just to be thorough.
The product key you entered didn't work. Check the product key and try again, or enter a different one.
Error Code:0xc004f050
It's requesting a new key to activate and tells me
error code 0xC004C003 error description - the activation server determined the specified product key has been blocked.
Windows offers this solution
You upgraded to Windows 10 for free from Windows 7 Service Pack 1 or Windows 8.1 Update
If you upgraded to Windows 10 for free and ended up in a non-activated state, try following these steps:
1. Go to Start , then select Settings > Update & security > Activation.
2. If your activation state says Connect to the Internet to activate Windows, it might mean you're not connected to the Internet or the activation servers are busy.
3. If you're connected to the Internet, Windows 10 will be automatically activated. You can also select Activate to try and manually activate Windows. If the activation servers are busy, you might need to wait a while and then try again later.
4. If your activation state says Windows is not activated, select Go to Store, and check to see if a valid license for Windows is available for your device.
5. If a license isn't available, you'll need to buy Windows from the Store or go back to your previous version of Windows, make sure the previous version is activated, and then upgrade to Windows 10.
Note
⦁ If you continue experiencing problems activating Windows 10 after upgrading from an activated copy of Windows 7 SP1 or Windows 8.1 Update, contact ⦁ customer support.
⦁ For more info about how to go back to a previous version of Windows, see the section in ⦁ Recovery options in Windows 10.
I might be blind dense or both but I do not see where you find a way to get your copy verified through the store.
Windows also offers this as a solution
Windows 10
To start Product Activation:
1. Go to Start, then select Settings, choose Update & security, and then select Activation.
2. If your device is not activated, the Activate by phone option will be available.
There is no activate by phone option on my activation page.
So all this was done as a test to see would this work. I'm not doing this to be an ass and call people liars or be difficult... I'm doing this for my own peace of mind as I would think that a lot of people just may end up where I just did.
A lot of people don't know where to go next.
If I give people advice that may not bring about the desired end result then I feel I am part of the problem.
In my theory it is probably due to the fact that I erased the 500MB original partition which was created by the win10 upgrade that this did not work.
I am curious if in your complete win10 installs that worked Drago did you erase the System Reserved partitions or just formatted the Primary partition and install to it? It may be that the validation is done through the existing MBR Data? Just speculating here. I would really like to understand why my installation did not verify.
I will reinstall win7 pro x64 completely and fully update. Attempt to reinstall win10. Use produkey as this has saved me quite a headache in the past and if anything else gos foul I will post back results here.
Good bad or ugly.
I hope that the OP hasn't done anything rash and ended up in a bind. Guess we'll find out if we ever hear back from him.
The message here is the process is not fool proof. This fool is proof of this.
I am a bit foolish but I intend to be thorough and if you can point out where I skrewed this up please do.
The final verdict is Microsoft is not definitive in the proper sequence or even in giving you a solution which is a. relevant or b. even in existence if things go awry.
That is where I believe the crux of the issue lies.
All this said... I still am perfectly happy with my Win 7 Pro. LOL
To Chris OMahoney save yourself some issues and use a keyfinder. Save your existing win7 key and the new win10 one when you find them.
Oh and good luck.
-John