[citation][nom]anamaniac[/nom]I love my CM V8. Sure, not the prettiest thing around, and it's a horrible cooler if you want high end air cooling (get a TRUE for that), but damn, even at max speed, I can't hear it over even my case fans and GPU all at minimum RPM.Though I have been tempted to slap two more fans on it (for each side).The sheer size of it though makes it so I have to remove the HSF before removing the first DIMM. Pain in the ass when I have a corrupt stick of memory.[/citation]
Not sure what the deal is with some people, but I was able to get my i7 920 to a stable (Prime 95 tested and been running for over a year and a half) to 4.1 GHz with this cooler in conjunction with Tuniq's TX-2 thermal paste. It's cooling technique is the same as the "best rated" coolers, and construction is good quality, so there's really not much reason it shouldn't perform very well, even if it doesn't come out on top by half a degree at full load in someone's single-application test.
Really, if you are going to publish tests of CPU coolers it would be much more accurate to set up at least a half dozen identical machines with each cooler; I suspect that if anyone did that, they'd find that the variations they see between different brands of coolers that are very close are little if any different than side by side tests of the same cooler. Certainly, thermal paste application plays a key role in results, and from what I can gather reading forum posts, many people don't get it, and don't use good technique. I suspect that plays a large role in some individual beliefs about cooling solutions.
The CM V8 imo looks very cool (no pun intended), and I must admit that, once I realized its similarity in design to other top end coolers, the looks swayed my decision about which one to purchase. Truthfully, I hoped to be able to reach 3.8 GHz on the i7, and thought I was taking a gamble on this cooler, and might actually have to send it back and get a better one. I was very pleasantly surprised to be able to get the results I did. (I don't attribute the 4.1 GHz result to this cooler, I think I got lucky and got one of the better overclocking 920s, but I wouldn't have been able to reach it if the cooler wasn't very good and my technique for assembling my system wasn't sound.)