intel g2010 vs amd a4 5300 + gtx 650 for gaming?? need help..

[lijith321]

hi,frnds

here am confused of the cores...
am not going for i series intel (no budget)
My budget is arround 4000 INR

1. Which is the best core with discreet GPU for gaming?
intel g2010 or amd a4 5300..?

I think in specs a4 is better..but i heard that the perfomance of the amd cores will not last.., i dont know its true..!!!!!

2. By ignoring the integrated graphics from these cores which will get high in perfomance??

here i have 1 gb nvidia gtx 650 GPU..

3.WILL THE INTEGRATED GRAPHICS AND DISCREET GRAPHICS WORKS TOGETHER???

which i want 2 select?? why?
g2010 + gtx 650
or
amd a4 5300+gtx 650


I hope i will get an best answer..thnx in advnce..

 

[lijith321]

The g2010 is about 30-40% faster then the a4 5300.

why g2010 is faster than a4?? can u explain please?

 

[farrengottu]

the p2010 will do a lot better than the a4-5300. core to core intel wins there. amd is really like 1.8 cores since amd puts two cores in a module that share a certain stages of the processing... i dont want to get too geeky here.

the p2010 does cost a bit more but still a good but under you 4000 INR. im assuming you have extra money for a motherboard, ram, etc. especially since these two processor options use different sockets and thus different motherboards.

 

[lijith321]

The g2010 is about 30-40% faster then the a4 5300. Also both opf them will bottleneck the gtx 650. You need a core i3 cpu really minimum for a gtx650 and an fx6300 probably from amd side.

but from toms hardwares itself everyone said that it won't bottleneck...its enough..!! :O

 

[lijith321]

the p2010 will do a lot better than the a4-5300. core to core intel wins there. amd is really like 1.8 cores since amd puts two cores in a module that share a certain stages of the processing... i dont want to get too geeky here.

the p2010 does cost a bit more but still a good but under you 4000 INR. im assuming you have extra money for a motherboard, ram, etc. especially since these two processor options use different sockets and thus different motherboards.

ya this budget is for the core..i know it requires different mobo..thanks

 

[farrengottu]

i dont think either processor will really bottleneck it. i mean of course you will get better frame rates with a better processor but these arent so slow that the card will be unable to do its max. just the game will not have the processor it wants to do its best. but some games are written to use as little cpu as possible and on those games this setup will work great. but on cpu intensive games like most MMORPGs you will be limited.

 

[lijith321]

but here amd has turbo clock..and intel doesn't...

 

[lijith321]

To be honest none of these cpus are fast enough. A4 is to slow for any modern game to be really playable. Also amd cpus are around 2x performance per watt behind intel. http://www.techspot.com/review/681-amd-a10-6800k-a4-4000/page8.html

You can see here g2020 which is slightly faster then g2010 beats an a4 5300.
http://www.techspot.com/review/681-amd-a10-6800k-a4-4000/page7.html

but 2020 is not available in my place..

 

[lijith321]

[/quotemsg]
I was only using it as a comparison and the g2010 is only 100mhz slower, no real difference in performance.
http://ark.intel.com/products/71071/
http://ark.intel.com/products/71070
[/quotemsg]

ya , i to think that there is not much difference...!!!
my current core is dual core e5200..and it is bottleneck..
any way here am going for intel...but i want to find that g2010 will bottleneck my gtx..!!
but here i have a doubt, amd has turbo, but still it is standing back in perfomance..?

 

[renz496]

even if g2010 have the same clock as e5200, g2010 will end up faster due to IPC advantage. the same goes to g2010 vs A45300. it doesn't matter if has turbo but if the turbo clock still cannot match the performance of g2010 then it will not beat it.

 

[lijith321]

even if g2010 have the same clock as e5200, g2010 will end up faster due to IPC advantage. the same goes to g2010 vs A45300. it doesn't matter if has turbo but if the turbo clock still cannot match the performance of g2010 then it will not beat it.

what about the g2010...? is it good one? will this core bottleneck gtx 650?