If you bought this PSU new, then I am surprised that it has died so quickly. From my understanding Corsair don't make their own PSUs and they are normally made by Seasonic and CWT.
If this was bought new then I would go read the warranty as I am sure it has a 2-3 year warranty. If it is second hand then you don't really know how it was used previously and it could have been on its last legs.
In relation to the 750W, it won't die faster because it is larger. However, if you can afford it you are best getting a PSU from a reliable manufacturer and one that has a good standard (bronze minimum).