Archived from groups: rec.games.frp.gurps (
More info?)
"Peter Knutsen" <peter@sagatafl.invalid> wrote in message
news:33jgmcF42ice9U1@individual.net...
>
> Eric Smith wrote:
> > SJGames has been conducting /closed/ playtests for a while now. To join
up
> > you have to be a Pyramid or JTAS subscriber, then request and be
accepted to
> > a particular playtest. Only then will you be given access to the
playtest
>
> Do you have to send the request when the playtest begins
> (i.e. you have to be a subscriber at that time) or can you
> request after the playtest has started?
I believe that depends entirely on the book being playtested and the wishes
of the author and lead playtester. The GURPS Powers playtest was limited to
something like 30 people (due to author time constraints), so if you didn't
apply when it first opened you couldn't get in. OTOH the Ultra-Tech playtest
was pretty much open to any comers, and I believe they let people in for a
couple weeks, which also happened when we playtested my Space: Starships
Expansion for e23. I'm not sure about the status of the other playtests
they've conducted.
Also note that they are trying to make sure to announce all playtests on the
Daily Illuminator at least a couple days before a playtest starts, to give
interested people a chance to subscribe and join a playtest.
> There's also a risk, although I don't know how great it is,
> that if you are permitted into a playtest, and then don't
> contribute enough (i.e. in someone's *opinion*), you might
> get a "black mark" towards being admitted into future playtests.
>
> That, obviously, couldn't occur with the previous system.
Apparently SJGames has decided that the good of having more open playtests
doesn't outweight the bad - if you're not going to be contributing to the
actual playtest of the book then they don't want you to have access to the
manuscript. I can somewhat understand the view, though I don't agree with
it. I rather liked being able to peruse the playtest files to get an idea of
whether or not the book would be worth getting, and bought a couple books
because of it (and avoided a couple others that I probably would never have
gotten anyway).
--
EricBSmith
http://home.stny.rr.com/gurpsland
@earthling.net http://firedrake.org/eric_gurpsland/