Archived from groups: rec.games.frp.super-heroes (
More info?)
A couple of philosophical notes: To capture the spirit of Moore's LXG,
it's probably a good idea to collect solo heroes, rather than ensemble
casts or portions of them. Getting these individualists to work together
(or not) is a major theme of the original comic, and one that could work
well with 1980s heroes too.
Ideally, you'd also want well-known heroes, archetypes if possible.
LXG's appeal relies heavily on name recognition, so the "bigger" the
better. In general, I'd go with a bigger name over a better fit, because
a bit of internal strife is entirely appropriate.
MSH wrote:
> TOUGH GUY
> John McLane (Die Hard)
> 'Dirty' Harry Callahan (The Dead Pool version)
> Lt. Hiram Coffey (the Navy SEAL from The Abyss)
I'd drop Coffey (not famous enough) and add Martin Riggs (Lethal
Weapon). McLane, Dirty Harry, and Riggs are all great examples of the
tough, tenacious, loose cannon cop. Alas, Riggs is a buddy-movie
character who might not work transplanted to a new team. McLane is my
personal favorite, but Dirty Harry is probably better for the LXG gag,
because he has the best name recognition. On the other hand, Dirty Harry
might overlap Rambo too much.
If you just want tough, without the renegade cop angle, Rocky Balboa
would make a great pick. However, with Rambo that'd give you "Stallone's
Greatest Hits," which would unbalance the story.
> MORE THEN HUMAN
> The Terminator (Terminator)
> The Predator (Predator)
> Micheal Myers (Halloween)
Only the Terminator works as a potential hero, and the Connor family is
integral to his story. I'd recommend Johnny Smith (The Dead Zone) or
maybe an "everyman" superhero like Peter Parker (Spiderman).
> TOYS
> Ralph Hanley (The Greatest American Hero)
> Peter Venkman, Raymond Stantz, Egon Spengler (Ghostbusters)
Bruce Wayne (Batman) looks like a great archetypal choice for a gadgets
guy with strong investigative skills. Also, the Bat offers an Alan Moore
homage element; Moore re-defined the character in the 80s.
> BRAINS
> Angus Macgyver (Macgyver)
> Rollie Tyler and Leo McCarthy (F/X)
> Chris Knight (Val Kilmer's character in Real Genius)
All good characters, but only MacGyver has major name recognition, and
he'd overlap significantly with the "toys" category. To emphasize
differences, it'd be better to go with a purely deductive, locked-room-
mystery hero, a modern Sherlock Holmes. While I don't particularly like
their shows, Jessica Fletcher (Murder, She Wrote) and Ben Matlock
(Matlock) are better examples of the archetype, with less niche
invasion. Columbo would be a great choice if he were a 1980s hero, but
the show seems to faded away in the late 70s, with a 90s revival.
> GUMSHOE
> Thomas Magnum (Magnum PI)
> Maddie Hayes and David Addison (Moonlighting)
> Sonny Crockett and Ricardo Tubbs (Miami Vice)
Magnum is the closest to a solo hero here, and even he has a strong
"buddy" element to his show. The 1980s didn't go for the solo detective
much, preferring odd couples (Moonlighting, Miami Vice, Remington
Steele) and ensembles (Magnum, many cop dramas). Dunno if there are any
examples good enough to fill the archetype without overlapping one of
the other characters.
The team should also have some kind of stealthy hero (like the Invisible
Man) or an exotic hero (like Captain Nemo). Wayne and McLane may cover
the stealthy angle well enough already, so an exotic hero would offer
more diversity. Ideally, you'd want some combination of male, non-white,
non-American, and anti-hero. Unfortunately, I can't think of any good
examples from the 1980s.
Here's one possible team:
John Rambo (First Blood) - angry hero
John McLane (Die Hard) - tough, wisecracking hero
Johnny Smith (Dead Zone) - supernatural hero
Bruce Wayne (Batman) - resourceful hero with a secret
Jessica Fletcher (Murder, She Wrote) - smart hero and "token female"
? - exotic hero
Of course, the story would begin when McLane decides to take a Christmas
vacation someplace quiet, well away from terrorists, like Cabot Cove,
Maine.
--
Bradd W. Szonye
http://www.szonye.com/bradd