Question Looking for 8-1 port fanless POE switch with integrated power supply

nostob

Distinguished
Nov 1, 2009
59
0
18,630
0
I like to replace my 8 port Netgear switch with a POE model. I run currently two POE AP's and one cam of this switch with injectors. I like to end-up with a cleaner setup not using injectors and several power supplies. I really need 8 ports at the current location. Some extra woudl be a plus. Realizing that usually the next "size" is 16 ports which typically results with a fan I like to avoid.

While I typically bought some sort of smart managed switch I rarely configure a switch.
I like a reliable brand/product

Here are some finds:

Netgear GC510p managed
https://www.cdw.com/product/netgear-8-port-insight-managed-smart-cloud-switch-134w-poe-gc510p/4773524

Tripplite 8 port un-mangaed
https://www.tripplite.com/8-port-10-100-1000-mbps-1u-rack-mount-desktop-gbe-unmanaged-switch-poe~NG8POE

BVTech un-managed 9 port:
https://www.amazon.com/BV-Tech-Port-Switch-Ports-Uplink/dp/B005GAATOG/ref=pd_sbs_147_t_0/137-9013369-5379943?_encoding=UTF8&pd_rd_i=B005GAATOG&pd_rd_r=0ee0d5c7-dc3d-41a3-8b62-badfc1536f59&pd_rd_w=XqEc3&pd_rd_wg=g92ir&pf_rd_p=5cfcfe89-300f-47d2-b1ad-a4e27203a02a&pf_rd_r=XW8D90CY4D09RPW6YTXS&psc=1&refRID=XW8D90CY4D09RPW6YTXS

Unifi
(I use unifi AP's, so this woudl seem to make sense, but reviews are not good)

Zyxel GS 1920
https://sviko.com/t/zyxel-gs-1920-8hp-v2-review-testing-cloud-poe-switch/40

Trendnet TPE-1020WS 10-Port:
https://www.newegg.com/trendnet-tpe-1020ws-10-x-rj45-2-x-shared-sfp/p/N82E16833156460?Item=9SIA0ZX21P7376

Would appreciate input on other models and feedback on the ones I listed. Not sure if I should add a Cisco model? I found the 250 and 350; however both with external PSU - but if I am not mistaken a true (usable) 10 port?
 
Last edited:
I guess the good news is switches are pretty simple as long as you do not get fancy manged ones. There are only a small number of manufactures of the actual switching chips and the poe chips. I doubt they spend the money to develop their own line they likely just pay a china manufacture to assemble them and put their name on them.

The ones you have to be careful of are ones that have fancy firmware, those the same exact hardware can work very differently based on how well the company that sells it write the software.
 

nostob

Distinguished
Nov 1, 2009
59
0
18,630
0
That makes sense. I imagine Cisco has the best FW quality but ahs external PSU. I am a bit cautious about Trendnet regarding support. But I do like the 10 ports with integrated PSU.
 

ASK THE COMMUNITY