Looking for Reliable HDD

Honestly, I would go with the WD range, if you dont need a super speedy disk the blue, if you do, the black.

I have only had great experiences with WD tech support as well, which is a big factor in that recommendation.
 


Maybe it`s a little bit personal opinion at the end of the day which with HDD it should`nt be the case but it is... But I`m not going to start calling you of all people a liar so yeas if the evidence points to the WD then go for it. It`s just a standard hard drive after all... Both of them are good established brands....