Mac Game/Trojan Wipes a File for Each Alien Killed

Status
Not open for further replies.

sstym

Distinguished
Feb 16, 2009
118
0
18,680
Clearly malware. Even if you warn them beforehand, the average user is very likely to ignore the warning, in this case because it is a game.
Try sending people low power letter bombs that will merely damage their hands, but with a red letter warning that reads "Letter Bomb, open at your own risk". Someone is bound to open the letter at some point.
Then good luck telling the judge it was a social experiment and you gave adequate warning.
 
G

Guest

Guest
What I would like to do is see if it would be possible to play without getting killed before all my files have been deleted and the OS crashes, sounds like fun to me, Brilliant piece of software really, and it is without a doubt electronic art in its purest form.

And if you read the warnings and still play knowing full well it will delete your files then its your own fault and that is just tough luck for you.
 

SneakySnake

Distinguished
Jan 28, 2009
451
0
18,780
I tried it out on my MBP on little while ago ( I was wiping the HDD anyways). It does what he says, and its a sombering feeling knowing that the better you doing the worse off your computer/files are.
 

copperbottoms

Distinguished
Aug 28, 2009
8
0
18,510
What a ridiculously fartsy idea... Digital art??

How does it possibly explore what it means to kill in a game? You aren't hurting other people like real killing, you're destroying your own computer. This is an exercise in masochism, not morality.

A video game with real life consequences would harm others through the player's aggression and harm the player for being injured or destroyed etc. If you're going to try and simulate real life consequences at least pick a reasonable scenario.
 

curnel_D

Distinguished
Jun 5, 2007
741
0
18,990
[citation][nom]sstym[/nom]Clearly malware. Even if you warn them beforehand, the average user is very likely to ignore the warning, in this case because it is a game. Try sending people low power letter bombs that will merely damage their hands, but with a red letter warning that reads "Letter Bomb, open at your own risk". Someone is bound to open the letter at some point.Then good luck telling the judge it was a social experiment and you gave adequate warning.[/citation]
This is an awful comparison. Think of it more like an innocent moron, walking up to someone's house, and finding a 'letter bomb' which clearly has warnings written all over it. They then take the letter bomb, bring it into their own home full of valuables, and open it just to see what's inside.

I'd love to see someone trying to explain to a judge that they purposely downloaded a clearly marked virus, ignored their anti-malware software warnings, and deleted all their files simply because they were too ignorant to understand what "USE AT YOUR OWN RISK" means.

How are you even accessing the internet?
 
G

Guest

Guest
Alien's fire at you in lots of those top down arcade shooters.
 

sqhacker

Distinguished
Nov 5, 2009
14
0
18,510
So in my opinion i think that its not malware, thats like getting a toy with assymbly instructions, if you fail to read the instructions then you put yourself at risk of destroying the product, i say the warnings are valid and it has many applications of study and psychological advance, but thats just my opinion
 
G

Guest

Guest
@Curnel_D

Could'nt have put it better myself.


Another point though... Windows/Linux alternative? Sounds like fun =]
 

mwbeatty

Distinguished
Nov 5, 2009
2
0
18,510
Moricon is absolutely right. Just like with anything else in life, if you can't read the warnings, you get what you deserve.
 

mustwarnothers

Distinguished
Mar 19, 2009
73
0
18,630
[citation][nom]homrqt[/nom]This concept is very deep if you think about it. Our brains are programmed to automatically start playing this game as a classic starshooter, and now we have to fight our impulses and think about the consequences of our actions before we actually start playing. I'll be rolling this article around in my head for a few hours now. =p[/citation]

I SORT of understand where you're coming from, but the consequences of our actions when playing video games differs extremely from the consequences of our actions in real life.

The whole point of video games, in addition to entertainment, is that those consequences are....inconsequential. We go into them knowing we can abandon reason, morality (if we so choose) etc.

Looking back on that one time I dressed up in a clown costume and unloaded an assault rifle at a water park, I really don't think having played this game would have made me thought about the consequences.
 

nekatreven

Distinguished
Feb 20, 2007
415
0
18,780
[citation][nom]nforce4max[/nom]Enjoy mac boys and girls you are now in the club.[/citation]

While very funny, this isn't quite true. The game probably deletes files belonging to the user that is playing, or asks to run privileged so it can delete other files too. There is no exploit there...the user is already supposed to able to delete files they have permissions for.

So, I agree that this should be flagged by a/v software...but I don't really think you can count this one against mac or osx. You could just as easily write a Windows game to do this.

(and I'm usually the first in line to make fun of apple products)
 

mman74

Distinguished
Mar 22, 2006
403
0
18,790
They got this wrong. Surely it should be if you lose a life then it deletes a file. Play this on your work computer and it will be like playing Russian Roulette.
Gives it a Tron like feel. Lose a life - lose your life, or at least your job.
 

joebob2000

Distinguished
Sep 20, 2006
788
0
18,980
[citation][nom]homrqt[/nom]This concept is very deep if you think about it. Our brains are programmed to automatically start playing this game as a classic starshooter, and now we have to fight our impulses and think about the consequences of our actions before we actually start playing. I'll be rolling this article around in my head for a few hours now. =p[/citation]

Are these tendencies ingrained in us because of these other games, or is it something more primordial? It would be interesting to find a pool of people unexposed to video games but otherwise computer-aware, and see how they deal with the concept.
 
G

Guest

Guest
His website has a clear warning - not sure if the software when run shows a similar clear warning (fine print does not count IMHO). I don't agree with producing a game that could render a machine badly crippled. However, if his program moved a file to a documented location, allowing one to get it back, I'd be a bit less hostile to the concept.

 

datawrecker

Distinguished
Sep 10, 2009
330
0
18,780
[citation][nom]SneakySnake[/nom]@ amplexisThere's quite a few games for mac, its not like the Linux situation.[/citation]

Actaully it is a small conversion to get Mac games to work on Linux. Windows games can work on linux as well with the use of WINE or other such emulators.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.