News Micron seeks reversal of court order to share 73 pages of sensitive data with China's banned YMTC chipmaker — Micron strives to protect IP from Chi...

[Admin]

Micron has petitioned the Supreme Court to reverse earlier rulings that granted YMTC’s legal team access to 73 pages of confidential 3D NAND documents, citing national security concerns.

Micron seeks reversal of court order to share 73 pages of sensitive data with China's banned YMTC chipmaker — Micron strives to protect IP from Chi... : Read more

 

[pug_s]

Awww, could sharing these 73 pages would reveal that Micron is pulling a sham lawsuit against YMTC?

 

[GenericUser2001]

Awww, could sharing these 73 pages would reveal that Micron is pulling a sham lawsuit against YMTC?

You have that backwards - YMTC is the one suing Micron, claiming patent violation. Micron is claiming that YMTC is abusing the discovery process to gain access to sensitive material.

https://www.tomshardware.com/pc-com...cusing-micron-of-infringing-11-of-its-patents

 

[pug_s]

You have that backwards - YMTC is the one suing Micron, claiming patent violation. Micron is claiming that YMTC is abusing the discovery process to gain access to sensitive material.

https://www.tomshardware.com/pc-com...cusing-micron-of-infringing-11-of-its-patents

You're right. Micron probably has something to hide, lol.

 

[Zizi Mai]

Shameless for Micron to steal YMTC IP. The world knows YMTC was the first to develop 3D NAND with Micron following later. There is no stealing of IP by YMTC as what Micron has is irrelevant to YMTC who had already developed it's own 3D NAND IP manufacturing process ahead of Micron. Micron's argument would have been valid if Micron is the first to develop & produce 3D NAND.

 

[PixyMisa]

Shameless for Micron to steal YMTC IP. The world knows YMTC was the first to develop 3D NAND with Micron following later. There is no stealing of IP by YMTC as what Micron has is irrelevant to YMTC who had already developed it's own 3D NAND IP manufacturing process ahead of Micron. Micron's argument would have been valid if Micron is the first to develop & produce 3D NAND.

3D NAND was developed by Toshiba nine years before YMTC even existed.

 

[thaddeusk]

As soon as a Chinese entity has the documents, you can't trust that they won't copy it.

 

[MikeH95]

Comments completely misunderstood the article. The 73 pages requested have nothing to do with the ORIGINAL 3d nand technology. They want the new, cutting edge technology information.

 

[d0x360]

Shameless for Micron to steal YMTC IP. The world knows YMTC was the first to develop 3D NAND with Micron following later. There is no stealing of IP by YMTC as what Micron has is irrelevant to YMTC who had already developed it's own 3D NAND IP manufacturing process ahead of Micron. Micron's argument would have been valid if Micron is the first to develop & produce 3D NAND.

Wumao detected, if you're going to make stuff up at least make it plausible.

Prior art.. sorry. Regardless it's irrelevant because they are trying to get information on other newer technologies via discovery because they can't replicate and want to STEAL the processes from Micron.

The government should step in exactly for national security reasons and shut this nonsense down immediately.

 

[izmanq]

As soon as a Chinese entity has the documents, you can't trust that they won't copy it.

sure, as if US can be trusted and honest 😏

 

[CNman]

The comment area is funny. First it’s the court ruling, which means court believes the 73 pages are necessary and important to the case. Not YMTC want to see anything so they get. Ps. It’s a US court ruling.
If any company is accused IP theft, and the
Accuser is on the so called entity list, so the company no needs to answer to the court rulings. Then it means US company can steal almost almost all Chinese IP (most of owners are on US entity list) and any Chinese company can do exactly the same following American steps. Is this way? I thought US always clean so they can always accuse others.

 

[ManDaddio]

The comment area is funny. First it’s the court ruling, which means court believes the 73 pages are necessary and important to the case. Not YMTC want to see anything so they get. Ps. It’s a US court ruling.
If any company is accused IP theft, and the
Accuser is on the so called entity list, so the company no needs to answer to the court rulings. Then it means US company can steal almost almost all Chinese IP (most of owners are on US entity list) and any Chinese company can do exactly the same following American steps. Is this way? I thought US always clean so they can always accuse others.

National security is national security. The Supreme Court should shut this down hopefully.
That's how things work in the US. There's checks and balances. And people have other ways of defending themselves rather than have one entity control everything.
Did you see what I did there?
So I'm just curious. Is it true that you guys scour the internet trying to make China look better like you are trying to to do here?

 

[CNman]

National security is national security. The Supreme Court should shut this down hopefully.
That's how things work in the US. There's checks and balances. And people have other ways of defending themselves rather than have one entity control everything.
Did you see what I did there?
So I'm just curious. Is it true that you guys scour the internet trying to make China look better like you are trying to to do here?

That’s how US works, precisely! You can use anything as national security even garlic. Then bend your law to suit it. Btw, I don’t even bother to make China looks better. Anyone can visit and see through his own eyes, and millions foreigners are visiting China now. For you, you know exactly how it looks like living in US. Let’s enjoy own life and no need to <Mod Edit> about each other. Honestly Chinese really don’t care about Americans these days, hopefully you can do the same. Especially when your house is burning.