Well, as a Western Digital representative, I can't really recommend a specific 3rd party diagnostic tool, but you could take a look at this article: http://pcsupport.about.com/od/toolsofthetrade/tp/tophddiag.htm. It has 14 free HDD diagnostic programs (both manufacturer specific and 3rd party ones). If you can find there the HDD manufacturer's tool, then go ahead and download it, if not - just download a 3rd party one. As for what to look for - usually when you complete the tests you'll get results and if there's anything out of the ordinary it should be marked. If you're not sure, just post some screenshots of the results here (you can use imgur.com to upload the image) and I'll take a look at them.