move resolution

[Guest]

Archived from groups: rec.games.diplomacy (More info?)

Thanks for the advice on the previous situation. Here's another that
I'm wondering about:

RUS A War - Sil
RUS A Gal S A War - Sil
RUS A Ukr - War
RUS A Mos S A Ukr - War

GER A Lvn - War
GER A Pru S A Lvn - War
GER A Sil S A Lvn - War

My guess is that War - Sil succeeds; because it succeeds the support
from Silesia is cut (even though the support is being given into the
space from which it is attacked), so it's a standoff in Warsaw, and
Warsaw remains empty at the end of the turn?

Thanks -

 

[Guest]

Archived from groups: rec.games.diplomacy (More info?)

Ker Lutyn wrote:

> Thanks for the advice on the previous situation. Here's another that
> I'm wondering about:
>
> RUS A War - Sil
> RUS A Gal S A War - Sil
> RUS A Ukr - War
> RUS A Mos S A Ukr - War
>
> GER A Lvn - War
> GER A Pru S A Lvn - War
> GER A Sil S A Lvn - War
>
> My guess is that War - Sil succeeds; because it succeeds the support
> from Silesia is cut (even though the support is being given into the
> space from which it is attacked), so it's a standoff in Warsaw, and
> Warsaw remains empty at the end of the turn?
>

You analysis is correct. Support can be cut by the space for which the
support is given, if the supporting unit is dislodged.

Roger