Movement and Support Help

[Guest]

Archived from groups: rec.games.diplomacy (More info?)

Quick Question:

If:

Austria:
A Ser - Bul
A Bud - Bul

Turky:
A Con - Bul

Italy:
A Tri -Ser
A Alb S A Tri - Ser

Since the Austrian army in Bul is bounced but Bud was moving to Serbia does
Serbia now have the support of Bul? Basically will Itally take Serbia this
movement?

Thanks for the help.

 

[Guest]

Archived from groups: rec.games.diplomacy (More info?)

In message <uuSdnQsmFtYbQhndRVn-hA@adelphia.com>, RF
<adeltech2@adeltech.com> writes
>Quick Question:
>
>If:
>
>Austria:
>A Ser - Bul
>A Bud - Bul
>
>Turky:
>A Con - Bul
>
>Italy:
>A Tri -Ser
>A Alb S A Tri - Ser
>
>Since the Austrian army in Bul is bounced but Bud was moving to Serbia does
>Serbia now have the support of Bul? Basically will Itally take Serbia this
>movement?

1.) Austria has ordered two units to move to Bul. It is unusual for
this to be sensible.

2.) You refer to "the Austrian army in Bul", but your list of orders
mentions no such army.

3.) You say "Bud was moving to Serbia"; but your orders show it as
moving to Bulgaria.

4.) You refer to "the support of Bul". But your orders mention no unit
in Bul, let alone its support for anything.

5.) You ask "will Itally take Serbia ..?" If the orders submitted are
as listed above (which I doubt), and there are no other relevant orders,
then yes.

Nick
--
Nick Wedd nick@maproom.co.uk

 

[Guest]

Archived from groups: rec.games.diplomacy (More info?)

Sorry meant to say Bud - Ser ....
"Nick Wedd" <nick@maproom.co.uk> wrote in message
news:NQ0ms1bPoOhAFAj+@maproom.demon.co.uk...
> In message <uuSdnQsmFtYbQhndRVn-hA@adelphia.com>, RF
> <adeltech2@adeltech.com> writes
> >Quick Question:
> >
> >If:
> >
> >Austria:
> >A Ser - Bul
> >A Bud - Bul
> >
> >Turky:
> >A Con - Bul
> >
> >Italy:
> >A Tri -Ser
> >A Alb S A Tri - Ser
> >
> >Since the Austrian army in Bul is bounced but Bud was moving to Serbia
does
> >Serbia now have the support of Bul? Basically will Itally take Serbia
this
> >movement?
>
> 1.) Austria has ordered two units to move to Bul. It is unusual for
> this to be sensible.
>
> 2.) You refer to "the Austrian army in Bul", but your list of orders
> mentions no such army.
>
> 3.) You say "Bud was moving to Serbia"; but your orders show it as
> moving to Bulgaria.
>
> 4.) You refer to "the support of Bul". But your orders mention no unit
> in Bul, let alone its support for anything.
>
> 5.) You ask "will Itally take Serbia ..?" If the orders submitted are
> as listed above (which I doubt), and there are no other relevant orders,
> then yes.
>
> Nick
> --
> Nick Wedd nick@maproom.co.uk

 

[Guest]

Archived from groups: rec.games.diplomacy (More info?)

In message <2fGdncFmkuYTaxndRVn-gw@adelphia.com>, RF
<adeltech2@adeltech.com> writes
>Sorry meant to say Bud - Ser ....

OK. So the orders are now

>Austria:
>A Ser - Bul
>A Bud - Ser
>
>Turky:
>A Con - Bul
>
>Italy:
>A Tri -Ser
>A Alb S A Tri - Ser

And your questions:
>Since the Austrian army in Bul is bounced but Bud was moving to Serbia
>does Serbia now have the support of Bul? Basically will Itally take
>Serbia this movement?

A unit only gives support if it is ordered to give support, so no
Austrian support is involved.

A Bud is trying to move to Ser, with the force of one unit.
A Ser is trying to stay in Ser (since it was bounced from Bul), with the
force of one unit.
A Tri is trying to move to Ser, with the force of two units.

So A Tri gets in to Ser.

Nick
--
Nick Wedd nick@maproom.co.uk