Gingerbread :
Depends on the games. Not every game can utilize crossfire. Try with proven titles, which are known to perform better in crossfire. Also I know it's stupid but are you certain your PC is using both cards, check if both cards are active and give info on their PCI-E configuration (are they running as x4 or x8 or x16 and are they running in PCI-E 3.0 and etc, not that it should matter, but still).
How do I check their pcie config?
I know both work because they are picking up, and I'll go into a game and the logo will be on the top right. Checked crossfire, enabled it for the games I play on steam, everything checks out.
Msi afterburner just shows the one card doing everything and the other acts like it's not doing anything. No fluctuating temps or gpu usage percent