• Happy holidays, folks! Thanks to each and every one of you for being part of the Tom's Hardware community!

Multiple Modems for small business?

roberts_zak

Distinguished
Sep 23, 2010
21
0
18,510
Hey All-

I work in a small office, we have 18 workstations in our office building. Currently, we have it setup that we have 2 x 8mbps plans and the internet load gets shared between these two modems.

But, the ISP now offers a 50mbps plan for basically the same price as what we are currently paying, so my question is would there be any noticeable drawbacks of switching to 1 modem that has a 50mbps vs 2 modems that run 8mbps?

Thanks
~Zak
 
Solution
No drawbacks whatsoever. I'm assuming you're using a switch for the PC's? The 100mb port on your switch is the bottleneck in this equation.. which is still plenty :).

Just for a little insight - I work in IT at a local college, we usually have 1 modem per building ( ~300ish PC's per building)
No drawbacks whatsoever. I'm assuming you're using a switch for the PC's? The 100mb port on your switch is the bottleneck in this equation.. which is still plenty :).

Just for a little insight - I work in IT at a local college, we usually have 1 modem per building ( ~300ish PC's per building)
 
Solution
Hi, I realize this is a half year old post, but thought I'd jump in. At my parents house I have two DSL circuits using the lowest rated internet/phone company in the nation "Frontier communications" on DSL1 we get about 4mbit/.5mbit and DSL2 we get 5mbit/1mbit. We have a Dahua (OEM brand sold as Q-See, EyeSurv and some others) NVR (network video recorder). This is an IP camera based server is connected to (18) 2MP and 3MP cameras. Not just on their local LAN, but 4 cameras on our farm, 2 cameras at my house, and 2 camers at my uncles house (I know that sounds weird, but think of it as kind of a family based neighborhood watch program, we can see each others front yards to both watch out for each other <aka Did you make it home safe type thing> and make sure there is no criminal activity). This also provides offsite backup, so if a thief breaks into one of our homes, the other NVRs have a record of it..

But I didn't come here to post about IP camera systems. I was actually describing that to say -- we use a TON of constant internet bandwidth, and the way I have it setup actually, is that I pull the video streams from everyone then repeat it back out, so source sites like the farm that are fed by a wireless ISP, only have one of us pulling from them, then the others pull from me -- I configured it this way because I have fiber to the hub fed VDSL2+ -- 50mbit down, 20mbit up. Whereas they don't. That brings me to my point, when I got my parents the 2nd DSL line, all I basically did was turn off DHCP in the 2nd modem and put it into the network. But that brings a whole host of limitations that I wasn't smart enough to overcome. So I bought a TP-Link TL-ER5120 5-port Gigabit Multi-WAN Load Balance Router - I plugged both DSL lines into it, set it for both Load Balance and Failover functionality, then setup virtual port forwarding for each WAN port, along with a preference for most all the common latency sensitive functions like web browsing, playing videos, Skype, etc to run over port 1 mostly along with a higher QoS setting than the IP camera video streaming.

In your case the only benefit for dual WANs would likely be if you used a second ISP. For example a cable modem. That way you not only had a sweet 50mbit speed, you'd have a load balancer adding the speed from the cable modem on top of it, and one of the connections taking over.

By coincidence, I'm actually installing Ubiquiti 5ghz wireless bridge to a friends house 4 miles away who lives in town with a 50mbit cable internet account. Out of sheer luck my parents live up on a hill and have a clean line of site to my friends house. So the TP-Link LB Router is going to have its 3rd WAN set to accept this incoming connection from town so my parents will have a 3rd connection. By itself 4.3 times faster than their TWO dsl connections. So finally we'll be able to stream more of our remote cameras at a higher frame rate.

If I were you, and you wanted even more speed -- Call your ISP and ask them how much it would be for an extra dry line DSL account. For my parents, the first connection is $49/mo and the second one is $20. If you tell them you just want it as a backup line, sometimes you can talk them into providing it on the cheap. Then get one of these excellently priced routers and bingo, you are nearing the 100mbit range.

Sorry for the long post, it was only somewhat related to your question, but it made me think of how I handled multiple DSL services and now a 3rd based on cable and thought I'd share.
 
By the way, something to note since I made my post. I thought a Peplink Balance model 50. I first used a TP-Link multiwan router and it killed our thoughput. So we went for broke and spent the $585 for a business class router that was for a home. The price is rediculous considering the max total throughput of the device is 100mbit and it lacks some bigger features. But when it comes to load balancing and routing certain traffic to where I want it to go, it is top notch. I now have two DSL circuits at 5/0.7mbit and a cable modem via the Ubiquiti PBE-AC-620 5.8ghz dishes (-0.51dB signal with speed test rates of over 160mbit per direction).. So 3 connections allowing me to move all the Dahua NVR/Camera traffic at 6mbit outgoing and 15mbit incoming with the QoS set to LOW for the camera traffic on port 37777 and the HTTP traffic set to HIGH for web traffic on ports 80 and 443 so interactive traffic totally flies smoothly even when I'm using 90% of the bandwidth. Peplink did a great job on this Multi-wan router, I just wish they put a decent CPU in it and charged a reasonable rate. With home users getting 100, 200, and even 1gbit internet at home - these routers should at a minimum be able to handle 750Mbit for the price. One thing to note, when I had a problem and created a trouble ticket, they called me in about 3 minutes and remoted to my computer and router and gave me the needed tweaks.

Anyway - that's the conclusion of what fixed me up. The Peplink router, and a pair of Ubiquiti dishes bringing city broadband to rural people. A total of $1100 and now I'm getting 85mbit down and 7mbit up total.
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00KXVBXEI?psc=1&redirect=true&ref_=oh_aui_search_detailpage
Reviewed here: http://www.smallnetbuilder.com/tags/Peplink

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00UCG8IT2?psc=1&redirect=true&ref_=oh_aui_search_detailpage
 

TRENDING THREADS