rubix_1011 :
Custom loops are awesome for really high end builds, but they require quite a lot of maintenance
They are not only for really high end builds, any build can run one. And, as far as needing a lot of maintenance, no, they do not. If they did, you are doing it wrong.
and in the end, what would you use a custom loop for over a self contained loop?
Closed loop coolers are cheap for a reason - cheap/poorly performing pumps and cheap aluminum radiators. I'd recommend good air cooling over a closed loop cooler any day.
As far as liquid cooling, I would get a sealed, closed loop. Much less of a headache to deal with.
Not sure what your experience is with water cooling, but your information about watercooling is incorrect. Also, you should be clear to explain that closed loop coolers do not perform as well as watercooling loops - more like good air cooling.
I've had watercooling loops running in excess of 2 years without any issues or maintenance...it all depends on whether you use distilled water and antimicrobials or if you are using coolants for color, etc. Coolants tend to have a far shorter loop useful life whereas well-prepared distilled water loops can run for very long periods of time.
That's great you have a lot of experience with successful custom water cooling loops, I don't. I run a PC business and build custom PCs for various specific industrial applications as well as specialized scientific PCs for various analytical instruments, and build small business PCs and do a bit of small business network setups, and then of course, build custom gaming PCs. When cooling is an issue, as it often can be a major concern in certain industrial areas, I have always recommended the closed loop systems, and then remotely monitored their efficacy during full operation. They work for me, so I'll keep using them until that changes.
I prefer using the closed loop systems because I don't expect my customers to have open their cases and inspect their cooling loops. I believe in delivering a finished product, the PC, that is ready to go when it's installed on site. I want a reliable cooling system product that I know I wont have to make a service call for. Custom water loops may be fantastic, but I don't use them, and never intend to, as they do not fit my needs for my operation.
But I do have a lot of experience with closed loop cooling systems that have worked very effectively, so I'm sorry you haven't the same luck.
Can you stop nannying my threads and arguing against the suggestions that I am trying to give to this person to help with with their build?
That'd be much appreciated. Thanks.