My Cdrive and all others are defraged However, the system hard drive is 97% fragmented. How do I fis that

DavePeaceman

Commendable
Oct 8, 2016
7
0
1,510
I have defraged my c drive and d drive and all the other drives except the "system hard drive" which says it is 97% fragmented. And it says it needs to be optimized. but when I click optimize, it runs for about 2 seconds then stops and says it is 97% fragmented and needs to be optimized. How do I fix this? And is it affecting my computer?
 
Solution

The reason why i asked your system requirements was to know if your system disk is either a HDD or SSD. If it would be SSD then the defrag isn't needed at...
In general, you should just let Windows handle this automatically. I think default is a WEEKLY check.

SSD's also don't get defragged anyway, so maybe that's what the reason is.

Anyway, no worries. Again, just let Windows handle it automatically. No need to ever do it again yourself.
 
I have been doing this. But periodically I defrag my C drive because the Windows automatic defrag doesn't do my C drive for reasons I don't know. And that is when I noticed that the "system hard drive" is 97% fragmented. I can't defrag it because it won't let me. And obviously the automatic weekly defrag hasn't done it either. My main question is do I need to be concerned about it? I operate on windows 10, by the way. So do I need to be concerned?
 


 
Thank you for taking the time to respond to my question. Yes I let the auto defrag do its thing weekly. However, for reasons I don't understand the auto defrag never does my C drive. So, about once a month I do it through the windows defrag. That is when I noticed that the "system hard drive" is 97% fragmented. And then it says, "Optimization needed." But when I try and optimize it, it runs for about 1 second and then stops and says the same thing. I use windows 10 by the way. So, is this something I need to worry about?
 
Thank you for your time! I truly appreciate it. I am on a HP Pavilion g7-1338dx Notebook PC. And about 6 months ago I upgraded to Windows 10. I use the Windows defrag. It automatically defrags everything but my C drive, (for reasons unknown,) so I defrag it once a month still using the Windows defrag. That is when I noticed that the "system hard drive" said it was 97% fragmented and "needs optimization." But when I click the otpimize button, it runs for almost a second and then goes right back to sayin the same thing it did before. Is this something I should be concerned about?
 


no. like I said before don't touch the system partition.
 

The reason why i asked your system requirements was to know if your system disk is either a HDD or SSD. If it would be SSD then the defrag isn't needed at all. But since yours is HDD (7200rpm), defrag is still needed.

Since an installer under Windows is defined as a program that takes a directory of files in one nice neat place and spreads them all over your computer with no hope of ever knowing where they all went, a disk defragmentation and optimization is needed.

Defragmentation - what it does,
Imagine a book split into several parts, some pages are over here, other pages in another room on another floor altogether. You will have to walk a lot when you need to read the book. It may sound silly, but this is exactly what happens to files on your harddisk. Defragmentation will put all the parts (fragments) back together, making your computer a lot faster.

Optimization - what it does,
Imagine a big library with lots of books, spread out all over the building and not sorted whatsoever. There is an index telling you exactly where every book is, but you will have to walk a lot when you need several books. This is exactly what happens on your harddisk, the files that belong to an application can be all over the place, anywhere on the harddisk. Optimization will bring all the files together in one place, leaving the rest of the harddisk empty, and will sort the files, for example alphabetically.

Defragmentation and optimization will not only make a hard disk faster, but also lengthen it's life span, because the disk will have less work to do and therefore have less wear and tear. Also, it will refresh and strengthen the magnetic data on the harddisk by simply reading the (weakened) data and writing it afresh. However, defragmenting and optimizing is work, so excessive defragmenting and optimizing can actually cause more wear and tear than it prevents.

That being said, for Windows 10 and 8.1, one of the best defrag program is: Auslogics Disk Defrag.
link: http://www.auslogics.com/en/software/disk-defrag/

For Windows 7 and earlier OSes (e.g XP, Vista, 2000) i recommend MyDefrag.
link: http://www.mydefrag.net/
 
Solution


1) Yes, we need to find out what's going on if it's an HDD (not SSD) and won't defrag.

2) You gave BEST ANSWER so did your question get answered?
I didn't see anything useful there, so I'm not clear what's going on.

3) I check my own W10 PC, went to the "optimize" section and do not get anything like what you have. If the drives are HDD then they are defragging fine, and if they are SSD they show that they are fragmented but also say SSD in the list so I know they don't need it.

You can also defrag an SSD to be 0% fragmented just fine. (you shouldn't do it as it wastes writes but you CAN do it manually)