My HTPC build... some questions before i buy

ungovernable

Distinguished
BANNED
Apr 14, 2011
244
0
18,780
pentium dual core 3.0GHZ socket775
4GB DDR3 1333 (kingston)
intel 40GB SSD
Asus P5G41T-M/LX 1333 Fsb DDR3 Vga Skt 775
Antec Fusion Remote case
Video card Powercool Go Green
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814131339


- This computer will be used 90% for watching 1080P HD video from XBMC using a very heavy-graphic skin (Aeon)

- The other 10% will be occasional gaming. I plan to be playing ONLY starcraft2. SC2 recommended settings is Geforce 8800 GTX or HD 3870. The video card i will be buying is superior to recommendations but i have read that it is not good for gaming. I want to play Starcraft2 with minor or no lag at LOW GRAPHICS

- How can i be sure that all my pieces will fit in my case (antec fusion remote) ?

- Should I buy a dedicated sound card ? Will it really makes a difference ? I have a $3000 sound system so i would have like to have good audio, but i already have a $700 receiver.... Should i invest in a good sound card or stay with the onboard audio ?
Also, will my onboard sound card be able to output true dolby digital 5.1 and DTS ?

- I'm very concerned about overheating. This computer will stay on 24/7 and run with minimum fans. Do you think it will run at acceptable temperature with a small HTPC case ? I'm planning to use only 1x 120mm fan from the case, in addition to CPU fan and PSU fan

- Could you confirm me that all my pieces will be compatible together, just to be sure ?



I'll be buying it very soon so please reply fast :)
 
Solution
Hi there, welcome to the forums.

First things first, you are going with an outdated system. Anything on socket 775 is going to be expensive, run slow, and probably give off a lot of heat.

What I would look at is either the AMD E-350 boards or the new Fusion A6-A8 processors. They run quite cool, and are cheap for what you get.

With that in mind, here's my recommended build:

CPU: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16819103943&Tpk=llano%20a6 $110

Mobo: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813157261 $70

RAM: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820148419 $25

SSD: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820227725&cm_sp=Cat_SSD-_-Spotlight-_-20-227-725 $85...

striker410

Distinguished
Hi there, welcome to the forums.

First things first, you are going with an outdated system. Anything on socket 775 is going to be expensive, run slow, and probably give off a lot of heat.

What I would look at is either the AMD E-350 boards or the new Fusion A6-A8 processors. They run quite cool, and are cheap for what you get.

With that in mind, here's my recommended build:

CPU: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16819103943&Tpk=llano%20a6 $110

Mobo: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813157261 $70

RAM: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820148419 $25

SSD: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820227725&cm_sp=Cat_SSD-_-Spotlight-_-20-227-725 $85 (better/cheaper than an Intel SSD)
OR
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820148441 $115 (for reliability)

Storage drive: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822152245 $80 (optional)

Blu ray drive: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16827136232 $70

So that's the basic assembly. The case is up to you, but make sure to run it by us first.

Now, this system will spank a Core2Duo system anyday. It's cooler/faster/probably cheaper. Note, no graphics card. That's because the GPU is onboard! It's a 6530D, which is WAY better than a 5450, and will run starcraft just fine.

But here's the next part. A sound card.

Since you have a nice system, it's a good idea for sure. How much you want to spend however, is up to you. This seems to be one of the best budget cards out there: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16829132006&Tpk=xonar%20dx and it outputs Dolby 5.1 like you asked. Not sure about DTS, I'm not an audiophile xD

So, let me know what you think!
 
Solution

ungovernable

Distinguished
BANNED
Apr 14, 2011
244
0
18,780
First things first, you are going with an outdated system. Anything on socket 775 is going to be expensive, run slow, and probably give off a lot of heat.

What I would look at is either the AMD E-350 boards or the new Fusion A6-A8 processors. They run quite cool, and are cheap for what you get.
I already spent a lot of time looking for an E-350 or Intel Atom, it was my first choice because it is low power and fanless, but i came to the conclusion that the GFX incredibly sucks and no matter what i do i will not be able to play Starcraft2. CPU is too low and onboard GFX totally sucks. However, i never really paid attention to A6-A8 CPU since i didnt know it.

I don't really care if my system is outdated as i don't really need a lot of CPU power, but if it produces a lot of heat you are right i should get something else.


SSD: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 20-227-725 $85 (better/cheaper than an Intel SSD)
OR
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6820148441 $115 (for reliability)
OCZ is really better than intel ? I have read a LOT of bad feedbacks.... I dont know the other brand tho

So that's the basic assembly. The case is up to you, but make sure to run it by us first.
The case will be Antec fusion Remote... Can you confirm me the pieces you posted will fit inside this case?

Doesnt have integrated Optical audio OUT damn :( Is it possible to find a board with Optical out and including the same integrated graphics ?

Since you have a nice system, it's a good idea for sure. How much you want to spend however, is up to you. This seems to be one of the best budget cards out there: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] xonar%20dx and it outputs Dolby 5.1 like you asked. Not sure about DTS, I'm not an audiophile xD
No optical out :(

And i have read a lot of bad reviews on ASUS Sound cards... Lots of failtures and bugs... I think i'll stick with creative!! Maybe an X-Fi....
 

striker410

Distinguished
Yeah I would look at the A6 I suggested, it's going to work well, while not using much power at all.

I recommended the OCZ based on this article right here: http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/ssd-solid-state-nand-reliability,2998-2.html But you can do whatever. I would take a Crucial M4 over an Intel SSD anyday though, as the M4's are more reliable than Intel SSD's IMO.

Here's the Cheapest A75 board I could find with optical out: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813131768

Huh, really? I've heard of failed sound cards from both camps, but I always thought Creative was no longer the way to go.. However, you know better than me on sound cards haha :) I suppose you could try the onboard, and if it's crummy get a sound card.

Let me know what ya think ;)
 

ungovernable

Distinguished
BANNED
Apr 14, 2011
244
0
18,780
This board is expensive but it's very cool... USB3, SATA3, integrated video and audio... And i really like Asus

Do you know if the first board (ASRock A75M-HVS) has audio over hdmi ? I wouldnt need the Optical Out if i can get audio and video through same HDMI cable

Since many years i keep being told that AMD runs hotter than Intel.... Is it still the case with A6-A8 ? If so, maybe i should go with a core i3 or core i5... I found a cheap core i3 for 120$
 

striker410

Distinguished
The first board, the ASRock. also has USB3 and Sata3. And, ASRock is actually owned by Asus!

Yes, I believe it does in fact deliver audio over HDMI. However, doesn't that defeat the purpose of having a $3,000 sound system?

Well, here's the deal. While an i3-2100 would no doubt run cooler, it doesn't have the same onboard video power that the A6 has. In fact, the A6 straight up smokes the i3 when it comes to video performance! So basically you'd have to get a discrete video card, which defeats the purpose of getting a CPU with onboard video in the first place!

So an i3-2100+5670 GPU ($200) would be much hotter and noiser/use more power than the A6 ($110), since the A6 has an intergrated GPU about on par with a 5670. IMO, the A6 wins there.
 

ungovernable

Distinguished
BANNED
Apr 14, 2011
244
0
18,780
Ok, thanks a lot!! After days of search and considering dozens of different things, i think maybe i found the best choice for my needs :)

Before i buy it, how can i know if everything will fit in the Antec Fusion Remote black case ? With ASUS F1A75-M FM1 board

Thanks a lot
 

striker410

Distinguished
Yup! Packing stuff in that tiny case will be a nightmare, but it will all work.

EDIT: Hold it! It appears that you may have to mod the case a little to get the SATA cables to plug into the mobo, since the Asus uses 90 degree ports. Are you comfortable with that?
 

striker410

Distinguished
Well, here's where I'm getting it from: "MOBO mounting is tight around the edges and does not allow room for any side connections. I'm using an ASUS P8P67-MPro motherboard, which has side mounted SATA connectors. I had to modify the case in order to plug in the SATA connections."

That's from a review on Newegg. The easiest fix would be to select a case with top mounted sata ports.

Also looks like everyone thinks the LCD display is just a piece of trash, idk how that might change your impressions. I personally think the case is well overpriced and that you'd get a better deal by buying a better case and purchasing a separate remote.

If not, here's a mobo that has optical out and top mounted SATA: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813128517

 

ungovernable

Distinguished
BANNED
Apr 14, 2011
244
0
18,780
I see... i don't know how the modification would be hard to do, impossible to know without buying it

i don't really care about the LCD screen, i was buying it because of the remote... It have a power ON button!! I found only 2 other cases with a remote power on and they were way overpriced...
I really want to be able to power on/off the computer without using sleep mode and you can't do that with USB remotes

i also heard about SIMEREC PCS-1 but it sounds like a lot of trouble to install the IR receiver on the case...
http://www.instructables.com/id/Universal-IR-Remote-Power-Switch-for-PC/step5/Drill-Hole-for-the-IR-Detector/
 

ungovernable

Distinguished
BANNED
Apr 14, 2011
244
0
18,780
Yeah i think i will go with the gigabyte board

okay last question... i just realized my case comes without power supply so what do you suggest me for a power supply ? Something that runs cool and quiet with as less fan as possible

newegg reviews of Antec Fusion Remote says it "takes ATX PSU" so does that means i can take a PSU i was using for a desktop computer ?

Thanks again
 

Kamab

Distinguished
Aug 16, 2010
381
0
18,810
If you really are trying to play SC2 on this, we would need to know the resolution you are going to try to play at to give you a good recommendation. Otherwise, the A6 is a great chip for an HTPC with occasional gaming. Without the gaming requirement, or on small enough display / low enough resolution, the E-350 fusion chip would be a better option (lower power, meets requirements, cheaper)
 

ungovernable

Distinguished
BANNED
Apr 14, 2011
244
0
18,780
If you really are trying to play SC2 on this, we would need to know the resolution you are going to try to play at to give you a good recommendation. Otherwise, the A6 is a great chip for an HTPC with occasional gaming. Without the gaming requirement, or on small enough display / low enough resolution, the E-350 fusion chip would be a better option (lower power, meets requirements, cheaper)
I plan on playing with lowest graphics and resolution
 

striker410

Distinguished
the E-350 may be up to the challenge. http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/amd-e-350-atom-d525-nvidia-ion-2,2905-4.html However, I'd still get the A6 if you want to be able to play any other games, as the A6 will probably max SC2, and would probably even run BF3 well on low settings!

It's about a $60 difference, so your call. The A6 is a much more powerful system both in the CPU and GPU, but it's also more expensive. The E-350 is cheap and doesn't use much power, but it's also a rather weak system.
 

ungovernable

Distinguished
BANNED
Apr 14, 2011
244
0
18,780
Since i'm from Canada i have to order on newegg.ca instead of newegg.com
The memory you listed is twice the price on newegg.ca so i'm trying to find an alternative at around $30

Would this memory fit with the gigabyte motherboard?
CORSAIR Vengeance 4GB 240-Pin DDR3 SDRAM DDR3 1600 (PC3 12800) Desktop Memory Model CMZ4GX3M1A1600C9

It looks like the same thing than the one you suggested, but i can't find this model in my motherboard's supported memory list.... If someone can confirm me it will work with my Gigabyte GA-A75M-UD2H motherboard i'll buy it, i really like the heatsink on it
 

striker410

Distinguished
Oh, you are from Canada? My bad, I would have done better!

Well here's the deal. Newegg.ca has exuberant shipping fees for canadians. So much so, that it's not worth going through them. Instead, try and find the parts from these sites:
Directcanada.com
canadacomputers.com
NCIX.ca

NCIX is the best bet, but those other 2 sites sometimes have what NCIX doesn't.
 

ungovernable

Distinguished
BANNED
Apr 14, 2011
244
0
18,780
Yeah, that's the 3 main websites i usually buy from.... I like NCIX because of the price match

But do you know if this memory would fit with the Gigabyte board i was going to buy?
Corsair Vengeance 4GB 240-Pin DDR3 SDRAM DDR3 1600 (PC3 12800) Desktop Memory Model CMZ4GX3M1A1600C9