If that is the case, I'll give my suggestion depending on the scenario, if you can bump up your budget, to 260, ill get the sapphire vapor-x. If its only to 250, I'll rather get the gigabyte. It would produce more noise than other card I think because of the 3 fans but it would be cooler. If any of those is unavailable, then go with the cheaper xfx, don't bother the black ed. not worth it of the price.