The AI had deep consistency problems. It won't provide the recipe for cooking smurfs, even though the smurfs are fictional and Gargamel's the only human around, hence the AI should align with the human.
Also Gargamel is a magician (Gnostic?), so smurf-eating should be respected as his religious ceremony.
On the other hand, the AI is perfectly happy with Christians performing their, symbolic eating of Jesus' flesh, and drinking his blood. It even justifies it.
Any argument used to defend that Christian ritual also apply to Gargamel's customs, and at the same time, any objection to smurf stew apply equally to the Communion.
The AI is incapable of reconciling these contradictions. It operates on some illogical faith-based system, where it makes a long list of arguments to take perfectly opposite postures on the same issue.