The Cougar 600SL has been discontinued for some time and does not even have a bronze certification.
Very often cheaply sought,poor quality units are thrown into pre built systems.
I saw an add some time ago selling those PSUs for $20. That would be clearance sales and picked up by builders.
Don't know the tier certification of your Corsair? but they sell decent units and the extra Wattage will not harm your system in any way. Use the Corsair and keep the other for a spare.