R2200g+GTX1050 or R2400G+GT1030

[absadalk]

I just wanted to know whether it would be better to have a Ryzen 3 2200g with a gtx 1050 or a Ryzen 5 2400g with a gt 1030 For me i can get both of them for around the £200-£220 range they both pretty much cost the same. So which one would be better?I mean better overall. In all aspects, editing gaming adobe content creating document writing, etc.

 

[zyh1987]

R2200+1050, I honestly don’t see why you would need to pair r2400g with 1030, sure 1030 is a bit stronger than onboard Vega, but differences are quite small.

 

[rgd1101]

why buy an apu if you going to get a dgpu?

p.s excessive tag removed

 

[vapour]

Do you have B350 MB and DDR4 ram already? Other components? Major usage?

 

[Eximo]

Drop the APU and get a normal Ryzen chip.

 

[absadalk]

Drop the APU and get a normal Ryzen chip.

what one could i get??

 

[absadalk]

Do you have B350 MB and DDR4 ram already? Other components? Major usage?

8gb ballistix sports lt ddr4 and getting a b350 tomahawk.

 

[absadalk]

why buy an apu if you going to get a dgpu?

p.s excessive tag removed

This is basically what i want to know. Ryzen 2400g with a gt 1030 if overclocked with quite a difference in the dgpu and ryzen's igpu; not *too* large. Or 2200g with gtx 1050 which nearly doubles performance of the gt 1030. So ryzen's igpu would be no where near as good as the gtx 1050. But then i get nearly double fps instead of the r 2400g with gt 1030. but what i wanted to knowis whether there would be a substantial difference in terms of the things I would use it for as stated in the original question.

 

[absadalk]

R2200+1050, I honestly don’t see why you would need to pair r2400g with 1030, sure 1030 is a bit stronger than onboard Vega, but differences are quite small.

ikr so thats why i askde this question ,what combination is better. I know the ryzen 2200g with gtx 1050 nearly doubles games and rendeing so forth ,but would I lose performance in tasks as stated in the original question?

 

[Eximo]

In your position I would just get the R5-2400G and call it a day. You can add a faster GPU later on.

If you want the discrete GPU, then an r3-1300x GTX1050, but preferably R5-1400 + GTX1050.

 

[absadalk]

In your position I would just get the R5-2400G and call it a day. You can add a faster GPU later on.

If you want the discrete GPU, then an r3-1300x GTX1050, but preferably R5-1400 + GTX1050.

thanks i definetely want to be playing fortnite at 60 fps in high or epic settings whilst streaming and recording
How much better would a r3-1300x be than a R5-1400

 

[vapour]

Not sure if you can do 1080p 60 FPS streaming with that.... but the doubled threads from Ryzen 5 is better to have for editing. I will probably try to get more money and drop in 1600/2600 and 1050 for 6 core/12 threads.

 

[Eximo]

In your position I would just get the R5-2400G and call it a day. You can add a faster GPU later on.

If you want the discrete GPU, then an r3-1300x GTX1050, but preferably R5-1400 + GTX1050.

thanks i definetely want to be playing fortnite at 60 fps in high or epic settings whilst streaming and recording
How much better would a r3-1300x be than a R5-1400

It wouldn't? R3-1300X is going to be a plain quad core. R5-1400 will be a quad core with SMT, so eight threads instead of four. Which would be much better for streaming.

If you insist on £220 then the R3-1300X and GTX1050 is about all you can get. Up to you if you want to spend more.