Recommendation for my requirements.

js-g

Distinguished
Jun 30, 2010
1
0
18,510
Hi all!
I could really do with some advice from knowledgeable people about a new router (UK).

I have a 1mb connection, (in the middle of nowhere) so bandwidth is an issue - I need a router that will protect my Xbox360's wireless connection, while the girlfriend streams youtube, iplayer or whatever.
N wireless would be good, as I live in a large house with thick walls.

I bought the D-Link DSL-2470 and recieved it today, but its advertised 'traffic shaping' is severely lacking, and absolutely rubbish - It isn't actually in the menu's as shown in the manual in the 1.13 version, so I had to naviagte to it by guesswork myself, and it then took 4 hours to make the rules work. It still lags when you load a video anyway. The G band is weaker than my old linksys (2004 model) and the N doesn't go out 10 metres through 1 non-loadbearing wall.

So instead of persevering, i'm going to return it or move it on!

What router would allow me to assign bandwidth caps by mac adress, or give a decent QoS rule, on it's own firmware.

I don't mind spending a lot of money as its still better than getting another line, which might be the only other option if we can't sensibly share a connection with the router. (Although the cheapest one that meets these requirements would be appreciated).


Many thanks for your time! I'm really glad places like this exist.
:hello:
Jos
 


I really can't see a hardware or software solution to this basic problem of lack of bandwidth here in our wonderful Third World of Broadband country. I'm sorry but if traffic shaping cuts off your X-Box or your girlfriend's video streaming at a critical moment, it's going to cause friction. I struggle here in what purports to be the most modern town in the country on about 1.7Mb with only normal downloading, sometimes to half a dozen customers' computers at a time so gaming and streaming on half that must be nigh on impossible.

Wireless N is a must for future proofing but have a look at http://www.samknows.com to see what else is available. Maybe an unbundled ISP can offer you more.
[/#000ff]