News Russia prepares 128-core server platform for supercomputers: Report

I do question how they actually think they'd make something competitive with the rets of world given even china that dumped a ton into the industry is still playing catch up..

I am all for nations trying to make their own stuff thoguh so hope it goes well.
 

bit_user

Titan
Ambassador
Did it say what ISA these will be?

The article said:
Given the fact that Taiwan-based foundries are excluded from its options (e.g. TSMC, Vanguard, etc.) due to sanctions, the only way for Russia to produce this CPU is to ask Chinese foundries, namely SMIC and Hua Hong.
Why do you omit Samsung from consideration? From what I've read, South Korea has been reluctant to impose restrictions on non-military trade with Russia. Maybe that's starting to change, but you don't seem to rule them either in or out.
 

shady28

Distinguished
Jan 29, 2007
446
319
19,090
You don't have to be on the latest and greatest node to have a viable IT infrastructure for industry. For that matter, the vast majority of data center servers in use are not even on 7nm, they're using 14nm class chips. These things don't just disappear when a new node starts up.

In fact, 7nm class server chips really didn't hit data centers much until ~2021. I know we just upgraded some VM infrastructure in 2023, brand new systems, using Ice Lake-SP. That's Intel 10nm (~same as TSMC N7). Unless you're Google or Amazon, the latest chips don't seem to be available for ~12-18 months after launch.

If you think that's odd, you'd be wrong. Look at Cisco's UCS offerings - all but the top end UCS blades are 3rd Gen Xeon (Ice Lake-SP), while the top dog is 4th Gen Xeon (Sapphire Rapids) which started mass production over 2 years ago. No Emerald Rapids.

~60% of the worlds 20nm-45nm production capacity is in China as well.

So sure, they are limited to tech that is very 2018/2019. Not exactly ancient history.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ivan_vy

Vanderlindemedia

Commendable
Jul 15, 2022
132
73
1,660
No organisation replaces its servers with brand new stuff. You need months or perhaps years of validation that the platform works as intended and within what your doing with it.

Those sanctions just uphold nothing, other then China to reach advanced tech by themself and without the use of the western world really.

China will sooner or later have better products then the west. Just a matter of time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ivan_vy

ThomasKinsley

Notable
Oct 4, 2023
385
384
1,060
As astute commenters noted here Russia doesn't need the best, only what works good enough. Given that Intel and AMD are now in short supply, Russia will go about slowly building a viable semiconductor sector. In the short term it will require foreign assistance but in the long term they might make something work, even if it is out of necessity.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ivan_vy

Chung Leong

Reputable
Dec 6, 2019
494
193
4,860
Given the low number of chips involved, does it really matter what tech is used to manufacture it? Getting fewer chips per wafer wouldn't affect the overall cost much, since R&D would remain the dominant factor.
 

ivan_vy

Respectable
Apr 22, 2022
201
211
1,960
No organisation replaces its servers with brand new stuff. You need months or perhaps years of validation that the platform works as intended and within what your doing with it.

Those sanctions just uphold nothing, other then China to reach advanced tech by themself and without the use of the western world really.

China will sooner or later have better products then the west. Just a matter of time.
don't need to be better , just have a good benefit-cost ratio ... and talking about countries with imposed restrictions to tech access, just take whatever is available.
 

ivan_vy

Respectable
Apr 22, 2022
201
211
1,960
As astute commenters noted here Russia doesn't need the best, only what works good enough. Given that Intel and AMD are now in short supply, Russia will go about slowly building a viable semiconductor sector. In the short term it will require foreign assistance but in the long term they might make something work, even if it is out of necessity.
software is the real challenge, look at how MooreThreads GPU endeavor went, amazing HW on paper marred with bad drivers and that hampered software performance.
edit:typo
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: ThomasKinsley

suryasans

Distinguished
Jul 19, 2008
94
45
18,560
Putin's regime is very adept to get a workaround for sanctioned goods. Obviously, the only problem for Russia is its in house advanced packaging for its Chinese made chips. Russian chips size is in metrics.