Samsung 710T or LG L1730B ?

Idan

Distinguished
Jun 28, 2004
18
0
18,510
is the 710T much better than the L1730B ?

Beacuse in Israel, the Samsung's dead pixels warranty is very bad. Samsung replaces a monitor with 20 dead pixels, and LG replaces a monitor with 3 dead pixels.

I see the LG 1730S and I liked his picture.

what monitor should I choose?

thank you.
 
It is extremly unlikely that you would recieve a monitor with that many dead pixels. more likely to have 0-1 dead pixel then anything else.

have a read of what Chuck_Hsiao says in the tread 'how common are dead pixels'



<b><A HREF="http://www.digitalgunfire.com" target="_new">DigitalGunfire-Industrial EBM</A></b>
ASUS P4S8X-P4 2.4B - 2x512M DDR333 - ATI 9500Pro - WD80G HD(8M) - SAMSUNG SV0844D 8G HD - LG 16X DVD - Yamaha F1 CDRW
 
BTW you wouldn't happen to have been reading a warrenty rating for an LCD TV would you... that might make a little more sence as those are far larger.

just a thought

<b><A HREF="http://www.digitalgunfire.com" target="_new">DigitalGunfire-Industrial EBM</A></b>
ASUS P4S8X-P4 2.4B - 2x512M DDR333 - ATI 9500Pro - WD80G HD(8M) - SAMSUNG SV0844D 8G HD - LG 16X DVD - Yamaha F1 CDRW
 
LCD TVs are larger but don't have that many pixels compared with regular computer monitors...the standard ones have a resolution of 1280 x 768 (0.98 million pixels) or 1366 x 768 (1.05 million pixels), which is somewhat less than the usual 17-inch or 19-inch monitor with 1280 x 1024 (1.31 million pixels) resolution. So they're larger because each pixel is larger, not because they pack more pixels in.

Remember that a company's dead pixel policy is just one aspect of their warranty service. It may well be that they intentionally set a high amount so that customers can feel better if they get a replacement for a lesser amount (or, if their monitor has a lesser amount). After all, you feel better getting 2 dead pixels when the company's policy is 10, instead of when the company's policy is 3, right? Just like any customer service, the stated amount is what a company sets as to what guarantee it puts behind its products, but in reality, how much it will actually replace for depends on just how close the amount is to that limit, and how much the customer complains about it.

With countries, it is somewhat trickier, because standards vary by country, so the average quality is going to differ that way. For example, Samsung recently came out with a zero pixel defect guarantee that's applicable to South Korea only. You can bet that it's because it's what the customer base demands in that country. Australia is another example -- many manufacturers have awesome companies there simply because that's what the demand is for. Here in the U.S., something approximating the ISO standards is what the market will bear, and so that's what the consumer gets, even though it does mean you can get up to 10 total defective pixels (for 17-inch and 19-inch monitors) and they still don't have to replace it. In a way, we simply haven't complained enough -- that, or we're willing to pay lower prices for one that may have defects, compared with higher prices to guarantee less. I have no idea what the market is like in Israel, and I wasn't able to find Samsung's dead pixel policy for the Middle East on their website. Realistically, you shouldn't have that many, if at all. If they allow up to 20, though, dunno, maybe that's where they dump all their defective monitors. Or maybe it just means they handle them on a case-by-case basis (i.e. the above). Realistically, other than mass marketing and having a quality product, I don't know how Samsung survives in America when their stated policy is they'll replace only for more than 9, when small companies like Amptron and many others will replace for about half as much.

Chuck Hsiao
Amptron
 
I know that its not sensible, but its the situation.
samsung importer replaces a computer LCD monitor with 20 dead pixels, and LG impoter with 3 dead pixels.

there is a big diffrence between the monitors performance or I can buy LG no worries ?

I saw the LG L1730S and in my opinion its picture is perfect, and the B model include DVI port, and someone told me that he saw the B and the S, and the B had better image quality.