Temperature Confusion!

Downfall222

Distinguished
Jan 27, 2010
6
0
18,510
I've only recently in the past couple of months built a new Phenom II x3 720 rig and I've got everything on default settings - No overclock, nothing on the stock fan (I added Arctic Silver instead of the normal compound).

What is confusing me with all of this is the high temperature that Speedfan is reporting to me, but at the same time, coretemp is giving me a whole different temperature.

What can I do to identify which device is running hot?

Thanks in advance!

Here's a picture of both of the programs reporting temperatures:

2a4v148.png
 
Solution


I checked HWMonitor too, but the temps are all approx. the same (within 1 C of each other). Speedfan, however, only reads one core temp, and it is listed as such.

Those temps are coming from somewhere on the mobo, but they might not be accurate.

@ Downfall222, your cpu temp is fine; if it gets to the low 70s (73 to be exact) you should start worrying.

Newf

Distinguished
Dec 24, 2005
2,010
0
19,860
Both programs agree on your cpu temp @ 46C. Hard drive temps in the low 30s are OK. The top 3 temps have no ID. My guess is that the 42c is your system and the 54+ readings are from video card(s). Hot readings to speedfan default settings may not be abnormal, especially for GPUs.
 

Downfall222

Distinguished
Jan 27, 2010
6
0
18,510
Oh that explains a lot then, yeah, I thought that the 58C one was my CPU but now that you've reminded me it's a high chance that it's the 4850 I've got :p So it's normal to have two temperature readings for one video card?
 

Downfall222

Distinguished
Jan 27, 2010
6
0
18,510
But how come AMD Overdrive reports all three cores at the same temperature? What can I do to fix this problem? I'm aware of the unbalanced CPU load but I believe it's from lack of multi-threading support from the game :( Which of these should I be most concerned about though?

I know that these temperatures are high but what is the chance of it being accurate? If there's a 40C reading on core and a 55C reading on Temp3 which one am I supposed to trust...
 

pepperman

Distinguished
Sep 15, 2009
1,105
0
19,460
AMD doesn't have individual core temps that can be read by speedfan or similar programs (if they even have individual core diodes), so those extra temps are not the cpu.
One ore more of those temps might be spots on the mobo (you might be able to compare these to hwmonitor). If you feel gutsy, you can feel your heatsink, gpu, northbridge while the comp is operating and get a relative feeling on what the temps are (please do not do this unless you are 100% sure you know what you are doing!).
It is possible that speedfan is reporting inaccurate temps, though. Speedfan on my comp shows the temp 1 and 3 varying from -20 to 103 and back down again while the comp is idle.
 



Sorry mate, but my Athlon X2 shows two distinctly different core temperatures in CPU HWmonitor. Next theory, please.
 

Downfall222

Distinguished
Jan 27, 2010
6
0
18,510
I don't think it could be my motherboard since I have a gigabyte ultra durable thing with that massive heatsink that has the heatpipes. Under normal operation (idle and basic computer stuff that I do all the time) it all works fine temperature wise, it's only when I start gaming.

What I am worried about (the whole reason why im posting this) is because I really want to know something. Should I be worried if my CPU temperature is that high whilst gaming but fine with everything else?

Please note that I live in Australia - It's the middle of summer :p
 

pepperman

Distinguished
Sep 15, 2009
1,105
0
19,460


I checked HWMonitor too, but the temps are all approx. the same (within 1 C of each other). Speedfan, however, only reads one core temp, and it is listed as such.

Those temps are coming from somewhere on the mobo, but they might not be accurate.

@ Downfall222, your cpu temp is fine; if it gets to the low 70s (73 to be exact) you should start worrying.
 
Solution