The $300 upgrade.

kumquatq3

Distinguished
Sep 2, 2007
43
0
18,530
0
System I am trying to upgrade:

Pavilion a1267c, Specs on HP website (see CPU below) http://h10025.www1.hp.com/ewfrf/wc/document?docname=c00617479&lc=en&cc=us&dlc=en&softwareitem=pv-39428-1&os=228&product=1847035

General Specs:

Motherboard: MS-7184. It's a 939 socket with 1 PCI-E slot. 4 Slots for ram (2 used). Upgradeable to AMD 4800+ X2.

CPU: Despite the above link, the CPU is a AMD 3800+ 64 XP, single core

RAM: 2x 512 PC 3200 184 pin, DDR SDRAM (2 slots available)

GPU: ......internal!

Power: 300w, single 12v, 19A

Monitor: HP flatscreen Max Rez: 1280 x 1024

Also have: 2 optical drives and 2 HD's (one Sata)

Goal: A PC that will respectably play Starcraft 2 (assuming Q4 of '08 ish). AKA give me one year of decent service.

I have read the "Is Your PC Ready for a System Update?" article and I will post the setup I have taken from that, but the key differences to mention are: 1) I likely need a new power supply, but not a new hard drive. 2) Keeping the monitor, and it clearly handcuffs my resolution, so take that in to account when talking about a card.

Upgrades:

AMD 3800+ --> AMD 4200+ X2 ($78.99)
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16819103053

+ Arctic Silver 5 ($5.99)

2x 512 Ram --> 4x 512 Ram ($49.98)
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16820161615

Total so far: $134.96 ($165ish of the $300 budget left).

Now this is where I have trouble, the Power Supply and the GPU. Let me just state that I can push my budget another 30 to 50 dollars if need be and I have some flexibility to "absorb" rebates by going over budget.

My "IMO" GPU/Power option is this:

Rosewill 600w +12V1@22A, +12V2@22A
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16817182088

+

7600GT (seems to keep pace with the 8600 GT, no Vista Plans for this PC)
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16814130062


Total $162.98 (without $15 rebate), and with a -$15 discount for purchasing them together, keeping me under budget. Then, if need be next fall, I could look into a new card to run Starcraft 2. A GeForce 8800 GTS 320MB or the like should drop in price by then. Or just cave on a new computer.

So, is this worth it? Could I get away with my existing power supply with a 7600GT (it asks for 350W's)? I appreciate all comments!
 

kumquatq3

Distinguished
Sep 2, 2007
43
0
18,530
0
Thanks! That does seem to be a better option and with rebates and shipping I basically sit at $300. Seems that power supply would hold up on a new rig too, which would be nice.
 

Wolfshadw

Titan
Moderator
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817371004
This Antec Basiq is a bit cheaper, a little less powerfull (But still more than enough).

The CPU you listed is an OEM. Meaning no heatsink/fan. I'm guessing you're intending to use your current one? The Opteron family should also be a possibility, but would prolly break the budget.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820145480
I'm not keen on purchasing two separate sticks of RAM. Shouldn't be a problem, but I'd prolly spend the extra $3 and make sure you get a matched set.

-Wolf sends
 

kumquatq3

Distinguished
Sep 2, 2007
43
0
18,530
0
Thanks, I'm taking your RAM advice. As far as the power supply, that would be enough for this setup, but do you think it would be enough for a "new" rig down the road? If 25~ dollars more buys me a power supply that I can use in the future, than I rather just grab that. Thoughts?

I am using my current heatsink/fan. I've read others have done it with the same 4200+ X2 chip with good results. Apparently they don't draw too much more power or produce much more heat than my 3800+.
 

Kamrooz

Distinguished
Feb 8, 2007
1,002
0
19,280
0
Ahhh..didn't know it wasn't a dual channel kit..Yea..Get a matched pair. For the PSU it's up to you really. Rosewill are Tier 5 psu's...VERY BAD...

Even though OCZ's modstream is a tier 4...their Xstream line are tier 2...with the GameXStream, EvoXStream, and ProXStream...So it's a safe bet....

You'll see quite a big jump from your current rig to this...especially in gaming...
 

kumquatq3

Distinguished
Sep 2, 2007
43
0
18,530
0
Yeah, the OCZ looks like it should hold up when a build a "Vista" computer in the future, so I think I'm going with that.

So is everyone "OK" with the 7600 GT idea? I figured a 8800GT 320MB was too expensive for me now and the 7600GT is almost as good as the 8600GT at lower resolutions. Worse case is I pick up a 8800GT for around $200 a year from now or a "9600GT" type of card.

Also, thoughts on the systems "longevity"

BTW, I REALLY appreciate all the help, thanks.
 

mad-dog

Distinguished
Oct 18, 2006
789
0
18,980
0
It seems like a lot of people get hooked on Rosewills advertising gimmicks or low price, when it comes to PSU's the ole saying of "you get what you pay for' applies.
FSP (Fortron Group) makes some of the best PSU's you can can buy and they are relatively inexpensive compared to other TIER1 PSU's, my first PSU was what i thought to be a quality unit (OCZ GameXtreme), when it cooked itself it took the Motherboard and VGA card with it.
Spend a little bit more now and pay a whole lot less later.
 

kumquatq3

Distinguished
Sep 2, 2007
43
0
18,530
0

kumquatq3

Distinguished
Sep 2, 2007
43
0
18,530
0
OK, What about this potential setup based off suggestions?:

Fortron Source 450w twin 12v 18A ($57.99)
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?item=N82E16817104954

AMD 4200+ X2 ($78.99) + Arctic Silver ($5.99)
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?item=N82E16819103053

Cosinar 2x512MB ($52.99)
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?item=N82E16820145480

Then the GPU:

Either 7600GT http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?item=N82E16814130062 ($89.99 with $15 rebate)

Total at $302 without $15 rebate

Or

X1950PRO 512MB http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?item=N82E16814161061 ($179.99 with $40 dollar rebate)

Total $393 without $40 rebate.

Do you think the X1950Pro would be a card that would still be viable next fall? Hence the cost being worth it short term? Do you think the PSU would be sufficient?
 

Kamrooz

Distinguished
Feb 8, 2007
1,002
0
19,280
0
Well if I was you I'd just nab the 7600 gt and save your cash....the x1950 pro is overall a better card and it will last you longer...If you have the extra cash I would recommend it...overall better card and it'll last you longer.
 

Kamrooz

Distinguished
Feb 8, 2007
1,002
0
19,280
0
Well I doubt that will be the case. They will optimize it well enough to play on older cards. a 7600 GT should be able to hand it on the lower settings...But yea..don't expect high resolutions with high graphical goodies..But considering we have no idea about the requirements it is all speculation atm...
 

zenmaster

Splendid
Feb 21, 2006
3,867
0
22,790
3
Here is a good power chart.

http://www.tomshardware.com/2007/08/21/energy-efficient_computing_options/page5.html#single_graphics_cards

The 1950pro can use just over 100w.
That leaves 300w for the rest of the system which is plenty.


http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814161060
$119 After $40 Rebate.

If you are worried about rebates since your funds are limited, the 7900GS is not a bad card either.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814133186
$119 w/o rebate.

Both should work with the 400w FSP PSU for $39
 

starcraftfanatic

Distinguished
Aug 15, 2007
469
0
18,780
0
get a cheap 7900GS and a new dual core proccesor and if you have cash left over more RAM, odds are SC2 is gonna be dual threaded and the 7900GS is alot better than any 7600 while not breaking your wallet, PNY is a pretty good brand
 

kumquatq3

Distinguished
Sep 2, 2007
43
0
18,530
0
I could "absorb" the $40 for the 8 weeks I need for the rebate check, so I was planning on getting the 1950pro Zenmaster listed 2 posts above. It's just faster, thoughts?

Post rebate and the 400w FSU PSU, it's a $315 upgrade (with a new case fan and shipping), which works for me.

Short of any objections, I put my newegg order in tomorrow night
 

runswindows95

Distinguished
Dec 24, 2005
2,715
0
21,160
147
Personally, in the long run, you're better off saving the money and rebuilding a new system. I've selling HP computers for the last seven years where I work. The reasons why you should just build a new system are these:

1) 99% of the time the BIOS on OEM mobo's are locked. All you can change on them is boot order, enable/disable ports and onboard audio and such. It's not like an ASUS where you can change everything. Also, the mobos are so propitiatory, you might not be able to upgrade the CPU at all. Just because it's a socket 939 doesn't mean HP requested it to handle dual-cores or allow you to upgrade it at all.

2) The cases are sometimes also highly propitiatory. I've dealt with HP cases where the PSU mounts were their own design and I had to go back to HP to get a new PSU because a generic one wouldn't fit. Also, they aren't well ventilated either. Most only have the fan mount in the back and that's it.

3) It's the fact OEM's don't build their machines with upgrades in mind. They are built for Granny Smith who wants to a computer to check their email. They were and never will be built with power users in mind. They use cheap, propitiatory parts to make them affordable to the public when they mass produce them.

Overall,to say it in another way, you're trying to make a Saturn into a Corvette. Again, just save up the money and build a new system.
 

kumquatq3

Distinguished
Sep 2, 2007
43
0
18,530
0
1) I double checked again with HP tech support, they tell me it can do up to 4800+ X2

I agree, the case and the motherboard are clearly not ideal, but if they are stable and I add a third case fan, I'm thinking a $300 investment is warranted, no? Especially considering the amount of things I can't play now and to raise enough for a system would require many months.

More Motherboard info here:
http://h10025.www1.hp.com/ewfrf/wc/document?docname=c00378480&lc=en&cc=us&dlc=en&softwareitem=pv-39428-1&os=228&product=1847035
 

runswindows95

Distinguished
Dec 24, 2005
2,715
0
21,160
147
Overall, no considering socket 939 is no longer supported. Also, every HP case I've opened (which has been at least 100 in the last seven years), they only have a mount for one rear fan and no much ventilation overall.
Besides, if your main concern is a game being released next year, start saving and build a new one. Both Intel and AMD are releasing new CPU's by the start of 2008, Nvidia is talking about releasing their new GPU's this November, and by then, DDR3 will be cheap as DDR2 is now. There's too much going on to jusitfy spending any money into a dead socket inside an OEM machine.
 

kumquatq3

Distinguished
Sep 2, 2007
43
0
18,530
0
My internal Radeon 200 i surprisingly capable for what it is, playing games like HL2 and C&C3 fairly well. However, Company of Heroes, Bioshock, and Heroes of Might and Magic V are out of my reach.

I think my PSU could handle just a 7600gt by itself, but with dual core and 2 gigs being so important to all the new spiffy Q4 titles, it might not be worth it alone. Dunno.

So I guess the question is, do I spend $315 for a system that should stay usable till '09 , do I start piggy banking for a new PC and just give up on PC gaming in the mean time, or just get a 7600gt and see how far it will take me while saving the rest for a new PC?

What's a respectable gaming rig from scratch cost nowadays? $1000ish?
 

lunyone

Splendid
Moderator
I woud get:
CPU: $59 Get while still in stock and cheap!!
x2 3800 s939
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?item=N82E16819103052

PSU: $48
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?item=N82E16817104953
FSP PSU in 400W flavor (your not probably going to upgade this system too much) or just get the 450W one KUM suggested.

Memory: $58 Getting 2x512mb matched sets works much better overall
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?item=N82E16820145480

GPU: $166 - $40 MIR = $ 126 Nice performing card.
x1950pro
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?item=N82E16814161060

Total Shipping: $324 - $40 MIR for GPU = $284!!! Nice deal.

Or get 7900gs: $126
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814133186
and don't have to use MIR!! Although the x1950pro will give you marginally better FPS than the 7900gs, the 7900gs will use less power, which would equate to less heat!
And if all else fails and you need to get a new case: $50 w/Shipping
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16811119047
go with this good but cheapy and still fall into the budget (if the mobo is a regular ATX/micro ATX configuration, not any proprietary form).
 

lunyone

Splendid
Moderator


7600gt would be the cheapest upgrade for ya. Not as good as a x1950pro, but would be a power miser, so you could be able to see a performance increase from your existing rig. If you upgrade to 2gig's of ram and a 7600gt, than you would probably see an increase. Moving the CPU x2 would give you more potential than what you have now.
One thing to consider is, can you turn off your onboard video, if you install a new video card? I know my compaq, back in the day, wouldn't allow me to shut it completely off in the BIOS:( . I had to always have 8mb of system memory allocated to the onboard video.
A respectable gaming rig right now from scratch, could be had for $700-900, depending on what YOUR capabilities are. Some people can really streach their rig (by OC'ing it) and thus save some original upfront costs. So not sure which way you want to go, but for me, I would probably get the 7600gt and 2gig's of DDR and see how that works. Than I would probably just save up for the next system that you build yourself, which would be in about a year or so. So try what I stated in previous build or do the ~$130 upgrade (7600gt/512mb x 2 upgrade). That is about where I think your at.
 

Similar threads


ASK THE COMMUNITY