I agree with you about the Mr. Yum and the mac thing but as far as video games or what was on tomsguide for reviews it really wouldnt matter who they used as the host of the show. As long as they have a good personality and love video games/tech then it will work. There will be some opposition but when is there not on Toms lol. Every article you read there is bashing going on but people are still coming back the next day.
I believe it could work again.. Grab that crazy old Janitor with a missing tooth that secretly plays video games and frags with the best of them and toss him on a show.. Ill def watch that.