Unofficial BBC News App Pulled from Windows Store

[JMcEntegart]

No more BBC News app for Windows Phone and Windows 8 users.

Unofficial BBC News App Pulled from Windows Store : Read more

 

[house70]

Fools. They could have offered him some money for the effort so far and hire him to maintain/develop this as an official BBC app. Win-win.
Instead, they chose to drop the fine print on him and now they have no app exposure. Lose-lose.

 

[Guest]

thats a big shame, I use this app on my WP8 and its great, shame that its been removed, I hope that they can sort something out to bring it back

 

[zoemayne]

I know for android bbc has a "pay for news" app thats pretty much why they shut this down

 

[back_by_demand]

BBC is supposed to be a non-commercial organisation, but in practive it is far from it, outside the UK they gouge every penny possible from selling DVDs of programs and advertising
...
If the apps in WP were free, but they had a pay-for one on Android, they likely have an agreement with Google not to allow a rival app on WP and have taken their 30 pieces of silver to not develop an official one
...
The person that loses most is the consumer thanks to the BBC being a bunch of slimy, triple faced, backstabbing Judases

 

[eiskrystal]

BBC is supposed to be a non-commercial organisation, but in practise it is far from it, outside the UK they gouge every penny possible from selling DVDs of programs and advertising

You think DVD sales and advertising is wrong? How quaint.

No, the BBC is not some magical "not-for-profit". They have a licence system in the UK and then normal distribution systems outside of the UK.

The official BBC news app is free as far as I can tell. I am also unsurprised that they don't want a 3rd party controlling the distribution of their content.

 

[ojas]

[citation][nom]house70[/nom]Idiots. They could have offered him some money for the effort so far and hire him to maintain/develop this as an official BBC app. Win-win. Instead, they chose to drop the fine print on him and now they have no app exposure. Lose-lose.[/citation]
True. I sometimes wish people wouldn't fix the problems of big corps, maybe it would force them to improve themselves.

 

[back_by_demand]

[citation][nom]eiskrystal[/nom]You think DVD sales and advertising is wrong? How quaint.No, the BBC is not some magical "not-for-profit". They have a licence system in the UK and then normal distribution systems outside of the UK.The official BBC news app is free as far as I can tell. I am also unsurprised that they don't want a 3rd party controlling the distribution of their content.[/citation]
Thanks, seeing as I live in the UK and have done so pretty much every day barring holidays in all my 39 years I think I know how the BBC is run very well, but thanks for asking
...
No, I don't think that selling DVDs is wrong but they shouldn't have advertising, that is a point of principle on which the corporation was founded and the license fee is the extension of that as a publicly funded organisation that are not influenced by commercial interests, if they transmit outside the UK they should have a subscription model similar to HBO

 

[back_by_demand]

After a bit of checking, BBC are launching the iPlayer App for WP in the next few weeks, as that includes the BBC News 24 channel that is likely to to supercede any existing BBC News App
...
I don't mind that, but axing an existing app well in advance of a working replacement is a bit shoddy and disrepectful of the userbase

 

[zoemayne]

[citation][nom]house70[/nom]Fools. They could have offered him some money for the effort so far and hire him to maintain/develop this as an official BBC app. Win-win. Instead, they chose to drop the fine print on him and now they have no app exposure. Lose-lose.[/citation]
Why would you ever go from working for Microsoft (an Fortune 500 software company) to BBC (a news company that's prob been laying off employees due to the web)

 

[eiskrystal]

if they transmit outside the UK they should have a subscription model similar to HBO

That implies that a subscription model is best for it's customers (or even available within a particular country) and frankly i'll take advertising over subscriptions. Advertising does not go against their charter to use commercial subsidiaries as long as they don't go against its "UK public purpose" and as long as the advertising is peripheral and not endorsed by the BBC.