Upgrade Problem: M2N32 SLi Deluxe vs. Phenom II X4 965

georgeleus

Commendable
Feb 20, 2016
7
0
1,510
Hello all,

First of all allow me to thank you for all your quality advices given throughout the years, your information was so great and accurate that for the last 8 years or so I didn't need to create an account, all the answers were just found here.

But after yesterday's events, even the most valued advice here didn't seem to do the trick in my case.

So here it goes:

{For those unpatient with long babble, please skipt to the bolded areas}

I have a 9 year old PC in which I invested so much at the given time (about 4 incomes) that I want to keep it for another 5 years or so. Anyways, I don't want to sell it or upgrade the motherboard, I just want to beef up this old platform in order to take it to the max, then seal it as is.

My actual config:

MOBO: ASUS M2N 32 SLi Deluxe Wireless Edition

BIOS: v5002 (latest official bios, 2010)
CPU: AMD Athlon X2 5600+ 2.8GHz, Windsor core
COOLER: Scythe Katana 3
RAM: 4x 1GB A-DATA Vitesta Extreme DDR2 800+, EPP
PSU: Corsair TX650W
CASE: LianLi PC-K58, very well cooled
OS: Windows 7 Ultimate x64

UPGRADING to: Phenom II X4 965 BE Rev. C3

All worked best until a couple of days ago when I managed to find a breaking deal on this latter item.

Yesterday I've opened my case, cleaned it thoroughly, removed the old CPU, cleaned the heatsink, mounted the Phenom, stuck the Katana in place and gave it a go.
I found the CPU correctly named in BIOS, but at 800MHz. No problem here, I managed to apply the modifications which I've read on this forum regarding my mobo vs. cpu case.
So I've:
- Disabled C1E;
- Disabled Cool & Quiet;
- Set the multiplier to 17x;
- Set the core voltage to 1.35V.

After the restart I was brought to tears (of joy) by the first show of the CPU Information tab, in which my Phenom was seen at 3.4GHz. I really really enjoyed seeing that frequency on this old rig.

Started Windows normally, waited for the CPU drivers to install, gave it a restart, then reentered Windows normally.
Refreshed the WEI and I nearly made a heart attack seeing that the CPU Mark from 5.7 or so (from the old Athlon) dropped to a CPU WEI of 3.7. I nearly fainted.

I checked the Device Manager status and the CPU was being seen at the correct value: 3.4GHz.

My opinion changed when I downloaded CPU-Z and saw the details in the picture below.
Core Freq: 800MHz
Multiplier: 4x (17-17) {what does this 17-17 mean??}
TDP: 65W {the CPU is probably 125W from what I've read}


How come a Motherboard with official support for Phenom 955 and capable of a TDP of 125W (stated for other CPU's in the support list) cannot withstand a same generation 45nm CPU??
If it sees it ok as description in the BIOS, why can't it manage it ?


What workarounds I've tried:
- Decreasing and increasing CPU Core Voltage, from 1.2 to 1.5V. No Success.
- Disabled SLI-Ready Memory.
- Giving voltages to CPU -> NB, NB -> SB with values seen here on the forum. No success.
- Installing nVidia System Tools. It sees the CPU at 3.4GHz but most of the fields are gray there, even if I accepted the License Agreement. I mean there's no info to go on for modifying something in there.

My requests:
What am I doing wrong?
Is there any official rellevant information about strictly this CPU not being supported by that mobo?
Can someone explain why this is happenning? I might not be a computer scientist, but as an electronical engineer I'll give my best to understand why the bloody hell any other Phenom II will work and this not.
Giving the fact the CPU is very stable in this form (ran Mersenne Prime 95 for about 1h with a max temp of 55'C on the stressed CPU), can I at least use a smaller multiplier to at least make it work at 3.0GHz ? (I didn't try it yet, it crossed my mind later).

Thank you for your patience.

And no, I really really don't want to upgrade the mobo because I'm very fond of this flagship for which I've payed a whole lot of money back then. I really want to use it until it bricks.

And the second reason is that I've already bought two nVidia 8800 Ultra and waiting to get the SLi taste. I've read It's the single board with DDR2 that can do a full 16x 16x SLi support.

Cheers.





 
I don't see that there is official support for Phenom II processors (or even Athlon II) although it's an AM2+ MB. Large discrepancy between power supplied (65W) and 125W for 965 may have something to do with it. If it's not BE version it's probably 95W processor.
Try downclocking it a bit.
 
If the board is nine years old then I suspect it would be requiring a BIOS update to support the CPU. This is a very common scenario. Even if the board claims it can support certain memory and RAM it often needs a BIOS update to make it work.
 
Thank you for the info.

I've started to take every post containing my mobo and CPU combination file by file and I found that another user (I forgot his name) resolved this problem with a program from Sourceforge named PhenomMrsTweaker.
When I'll return to the office I'll try it.

As for the BIOS update I'm totally feeling you... but you see, ASUS didn't seem to find useful another BIOS upgrade, in order to support the latest X4 Phenoms.

As I said, what intrigues me most is that the BIOS really sees the name and revision of the CPU as they should be... now are thos info in the BIOS chip or read dirrectly from the CPU?
Because in the last case I'll have to find some possibility to modify the BIOS or find an unofficial release in which I can trust.

Complicated, I know...
 
Bios reads data from CPU itself but what it does with it is another story. BIOS is translator between CPU and OS so it has to be aware of every single function in it. It's firmware is just to small to keep data about every possible CPU that may fit the board, it has to go only by what that particular CPU provides.
 
Amess, that was the solution. PMT does the trick.

Now let me ask you fellas what I've also asked in the overclok.net site:

What I don't understand:
1) Why doesn't Windows see from the start the correct CPU speed if in BIOS all power saving and power efficiency is off and the CPU is shown with it's real name, code, rev. and frequency?
2) Why do CoreTemp and CPU-Z still see a Max TDP of 65W, even after using PMT ? I mean... the board does up to 125W of power.
3) Is there any possibility to make the bloody system boot with x17 multiplier default settings? After rebooting it restarts in 800MHz, although I've cancelled the rest of the states by setting them all to x17 ? Am I going to be stuck with applying this procedure every time I start my PC?
4) Is 1.35V for 3.4GHz/x17multiplier ok or should I throttle it back a little?
I've ran Mersenne Prime 95 for about 4 hours and other benchmarks for a couple of hours and the system is rock steady. I'm not very fond of the temperatures, but I'll blame it on the cheap china thermal compound used; I really need to get some quality stuff on there. (it idles at around 45'C, and maxes out at 68'C).
5) Is there any custom BIOS for this mobo after the 5002 beta release ? (because ASUS has been such a lazy arse and shut the gate there).
6) What are the correct values in my case for the following ? Should I modify something or let it all as is ?
Tuning: {Manual, otherwise the CPU doesn't work}
CPU Frequency: {200}
PCIEX 1 Clock {auto}
PCIEX 2 Clock {auto}
DDR 2 Voltage {I'm using 2.050V, under 2V I get artifacts; can the MTBF of the memory decrease dramatically if the voltage is slightly higher?}
CPU Voltage {1.35V now}
CPU Vcore OFfset Voltage {Disabled}
DDR2 Term Voltage {0.5x}
CPU to NB HT Voltage {Auto}
NB to SB HT Voltage {Auto}
NB Core / PCI-E Voltage {Auto}
SB Core / PCI-E Voltage {Auto}
SB Standby Core Voltage {+1.5V}
AMD Virtualization {Disabled}
AMD CPU C1E Support {Disabled}
SLI Ready Memory {High Performance}
SLI Ready Memory CPUOC {0%}
AMD Live! {Disabled}
AMD C&Q {Disabled}


Shall I change something in this setup? I really want this computer to serve me for another 10 years, as it flawlessly did the first 10.

For now I'll be concentrating on getting some good thermal compound and mounting two 14cm additional fans on my case (LianLi Lancool PC-K58).

Anyways, the CPU looks great in test results, and I'm really sensing the performance difference.

If you have any other advice for me, please feel free.


A pal named GYRO, owning the same mobo, answered in the overclocker forum and shared some light in my thoughts.
If any of you have anything else to add... please feel free.